The World Opinion

Tag: Thanjavur

  • No keep on CBI probe in Thanjavur pupil suicide case

    By means of Categorical Information Carrier

    NEW DELHI: The Ideally suited Court docket on Monday refused to stick the January 31 order of the Madurai Bench of the Madras Top Court docket shifting the probe into the suicide of a pupil in Thanjavur from Tamil Nadu police to the CBI. A bench of Justices Sanjiv Khanna and Bela M Trivedi, which stated the investigation will proceed as consistent with the HC order, issued a realize to the lady’s father searching for his reaction to a plea filed by way of Tamil Nadu difficult the order of the HC.

    The lady was once a Magnificence 12 pupil at a faculty in Michaelpatti. She had tried to die by way of suicide on January 9 and succumbed 10 days later. After her loss of life, positive video clips, that have been taken when the lady was once below remedy at a clinic, surfaced on social media. 

    In a single video clip, the lady had allegedly stated she was once forced by way of the college control to transform to Christianity two years in the past and was once additionally pressured by way of college government to do chores. The highest court docket stated that there are two facets to the case — one is bound observations within the impugned judgment and the second in regards to the order directing for a probe by way of the CBI. The apex court docket stated it may not be suitable for it to interject within the investigation of the CBI however it’s going to factor realize at the first facet.

    Right through the listening to, the bench requested senior suggest Mukul Rohatgi, who was once representing the Tamil Nadu DGP, if the police had been aggrieved by way of each the opposed observations and the general instructions. Rohatgi spoke back that the criticism was once with appreciate to each facets.

    ‘State will have to no longer make this a status factor’

    “With nice appreciate, this was once no longer a case of another ramifications. The Top Courts intrude and day-today orders are handed. A demise declaration is on file. This isn’t a phenomenal case. This isn’t a case that are supposed to replicate at the police of the state. Why any such large factor is made about it? On a daily basis HC is passing order,” Rohatgi submitted.

    Senior Recommend P Wilson, showing for the State, submitted that the one bench overstepped the jurisdiction by way of ordering the CBI probe. At this the bench stated, “So far as the investigation with CBI, let it pass on. Mr Wilson, move at the proof accrued to CBI.” Justice Khanna additional added that the State will have to no longer make this a status factor.

    Violated jurisdiction
    Senior Recommend P Wilson, showing for the State, submitted that the one bench overstepped his jurisdiction by way of ordering the CBI probe

  • TN seeks keep on Thanjavur scholar suicide case switch to CBI

    Through Specific Information Carrier

    NEW DELHI: Tamil Nadu on Thursday moved the Ideal Courtroom towards the Madras Top Courtroom’s order moving the probe into the Thanjavur scholar’s demise by way of suicide to the CBI. In the meantime, the 17-year-old woman’s father filed a caveat petition within the most sensible courtroom.

    The Madurai Bench of the Madras Top Courtroom transferred the probe to the CBI on Monday following a plea filed by way of the woman’s father which said that he had misplaced religion within the State police, which was once investigating the case. 

    The circle of relatives of the woman has alleged she confronted harassment on the college as they’d refused to go through a spiritual conversion and accused the police of leaking movies of the woman’s death declaration. State training officers and police have dominated out drive to transform as an element within the case. 

    Police had additionally claimed the woman had problems together with her stepmother. In its attraction sooner than the SC, the State has sought a keep at the Madurai Bench’s order and contended {that a} mere press convention by way of the police, ruling out the spiritual conversion attitude, isn’t sufficient to switch the case. 

    The HC, in its ruling, stated there was once an “try of the police to derail the investigation” and famous the woman had no longer made any allegations referring to her stepmother within the police remark or death declaration. 
    The kid had tried to take her existence on January 9, after allegedly being compelled to accomplish home chores. She died on January 19 with out responding to remedy. Police therefore arrested and remanded the warden accused of harassing her.