The World Opinion

Tag: Space industry

  • Some other smartphone helps satellite tv for pc connectivity, as cellular area race heats up

    British smartphone company Bullitt on Friday introduced a brand new telephone in a position to sending textual content messages by means of area, becoming a member of a crowded race to commercialize satellite-enabled units.

    The telephone, which matches into the “rugged” class of sturdy handsets, is available in two variations: the Caterpillar-branded Cat S75, which is aimed on the Eu marketplace and can retail for 599 euros ($634.49), and the Motorola Defy 2, which caters to North The united states at a $599 beginning value.

    Each telephones include 5G connectivity, a 6.6-inch show and 5,000 milliampere-hour battery, which Bullitt says can last as long as two complete days.

    With Bullitt’s telephones, a message is beamed to geostationary satellites about 22,000 miles above the equator, then despatched backtrack to earth-based community infrastructure prior to achieving a consumer’s tool.

    The consumer receives the message as a normal SMS. They’re going to must have Bullitt Messenger — the company’s proprietary satellite tv for pc messaging app — put in with a view to answer. 

    Texts take round 10 seconds to move thru, versus the near-instant pace of mobile phones. Satellite tv for pc connection is simplest became on when a consumer falls out of doors the succeed in of Wi-Fi or cellular community alerts.

    Information of Bullitt’s new telephones comes no longer lengthy after Apple introduced the release of its iPhone 14, which has a function for contacting emergency services and products by means of satellite tv for pc. The function is to be had within the U.S., U.Ok., France, Germany and Eire.

    Tool makers like Apple and chip companies like Qualcomm are making a bet at the untapped alternative of placing satellite tv for pc telephones within the fingers of folks in far flung spaces that fall out of doors the succeed in of terrestrial telecoms infrastructure.

    Connecting to satellites permits messages to succeed in large swathes of land no longer captured by means of earth-based cell apparatus. Mobile towers are extra restricted in vary, that means if you happen to stray too a ways from one, you’ll be able to lose sign.

    It will turn out to be useful, if you are a hiker who is gotten misplaced on a mountain path in a far-flung position, or a employee on a far flung construction website who must touch their boss, however can not get admission to cellular information.

    Satellite tv for pc telephones were within the works for many years, however have no longer but entered mainstream utilization. Bullitt is hoping to modify this with its equipment. Many satellite tv for pc telephones are clunky oblong gadgets with massive, visual antennae. However Bullitt’s telephones appear to be common smartphones, thank you partly to a satellite-enabled chip from Taiwanese semiconductor company MediaTek.

    “That is usually no longer a gimmick,” Tim Shepherd, Bullitt’s senior director of packages and product advertising, advised CNBC.

    “Dependable verbal exchange past the standard reaches of the cell community is a significant factor for a large number of folks, and satellite tv for pc generation is now on the proper degree of adulthood to handle the issue.”

    Bullitt says that its telephones pass a step additional than the ones of Apple, enabling two-way SMS messages, in addition to an emergency SOS function which the corporate has advanced in partnership with important match control company Focuspoint Global.

    Charges for Bullitt’s two-way messaging carrier are set at 4.99 euros for a fundamental plan with 30 messages a month, 9.99 euros for 125 messages a month, and 29.99 euros for 400 messages monthly.

    When compared, rival company Garmin fees £19 for 10 texts a month, £32 for 60 texts a month, and £58 for 250 per month texts, on most sensible of a £35 one-time activation charge.

    Apple’s Emergency SOS function, which doesn’t allow two-way messaging, is loose for 2 years after the activation of an iPhone 14 or iPhone 14 Professional.

    The iPhone maker hasn’t disclosed pricing for the carrier, as soon as that duration ends.

    Bullitt could also be launching a Bluetooth accent, the Motorola Defy Satellite tv for pc Hyperlink, that shall we any Android or iOS tool connect with its Bullitt Satellite tv for pc Messenger app, successfully enabling any telephone to change into a satellite tv for pc telephone. The puck-shaped tool, which retails at $99, can be to be had in the second one quarter.

    Ben Wooden, lead analyst at CCS Perception, mentioned that Bullitt was once focused on a distinct segment marketplace, and that its answer was once higher fitted to nations with massive land lots, just like the U.S. and Australia.

    “The corporate is a trailblazer for satellite tv for pc messaging however pageant is snapping at its heels,” Wooden advised CNBC. “That mentioned, the objective marketplace for its units is definitely fitted to the generation so it has a profitable area of interest to focus on.”

    Bullitt will enhance satellite tv for pc protection in Europe and North The united states at release, with Australia and New Zealand, Africa and Latin The united states to observe by means of mid-2023.

    The corporate was once in the past accountable for what it referred to as the sector’s first thermal imaging smartphone, the Cat S60, in 2016. On the time, the company mentioned it believed the function could be in 50% of smartphones in 5 years, a prediction that didn’t come to fruition.

  • SpaceX adjusts Starlink per month pricing for residential shoppers according to provider capability

    A Starlink person terminal, often referred to as an antenna or satellite tv for pc dish, at the roof of a construction.

    SpaceX

    Elon Musk’s SpaceX rolled out new costs for residential Starlink shoppers according to the corporate’s capability to ship provider, consistent with emails to shoppers reviewed via CNBC.

    The adjustments, defined on Tuesday, cut up residential customers of its satellite tv for pc web provider into spaces of “restricted capability” and “extra capability.” Costs will upward push $10 per thirty days, to $120, for customers in restricted capability spaces, whilst costs will drop $20 a month, to $90, for the ones in extra capability spaces. The brand new pricing will take impact on April 24.

    The corporate additionally made adjustments to pricing for its RV shoppers, expanding the provider value via $15 a month to $150.

    The fee changes come a few 12 months after SpaceX hiked costs around the board for services, bringing up “over the top ranges of inflation.”

    Join right here to obtain weekly editions of CNBC’s Making an investment in Area e-newsletter.

    SpaceX continues to extend its Starlink community via common satellite tv for pc launches, with just about 4,000 introduced up to now. Its provider reached 1 million subscribers in December and it’s often increasing its product choices — promoting services and products to residential, trade, RV, maritime and aviation shoppers.

    Previous this month, SpaceX management introduced that Starlink “had a money drift sure quarter” in 2022 as it really works to make the trade winning.

  • Terran Orbital inventory surges after profitable $2.4 billion contract to construct satellites for Rivada

    The corporate’s banner above the New York Inventory Trade on March 28, 2022.

    Terran Orbital

    Terran Orbital stocks surged in buying and selling on Wednesday, after the corporate introduced a $2.4 billion contract to construct communications satellites for Rivada House Networks.

    The spacecraft builder will design, manufacture and deploy 288 satellites for Rivada out of Terran’s Tyvak subsidiary based totally in Irvine, California. It’s going to additionally construct 12 spare satellites, for a complete contract of 300 satellites, and increase parts of the bottom reinforce.

    Rivada objectives to start out launching the constellation as early as 2025. The corporate needs to construct an interconnected world satellite tv for pc community, with carrier to telecommunications, endeavor and govt markets.

    “We’re ecstatic to paintings along Rivada and sit up for development out their LEO constellation,” Terran cofounder, chairman and CEO Marc Bell mentioned in a remark.

    Terran inventory jumped up to 75% in buying and selling from its earlier shut of $1.71 a percentage. The inventory has slid incessantly since its debut simply over a 12 months in the past, when it completed its first day of buying and selling at $11.80 a percentage.

    Enroll right here to obtain weekly editions of CNBC’s Making an investment in House e-newsletter.

  • NASA’s $3.5 billion plan to revamp its growing older spacesuits

    NASA has been the usage of the present spacesuits at the World House Station for many years and they’re appearing their age.

    “The spacesuits which can be getting used now within the World House Station by means of NASA are fits that had been actually designed within the ’70s. Those are fits that had been at the beginning designed for the gap travel program. Because of the loss of investment, NASA saved running on them, saved repairing them and keeping up them for a lot of these a few years. However actually, those are fits which can be on the finish in their helpful existence,” says Pablo De León, director of the Human Spaceflight Laboratory on the College of North Dakota.

    NASA has had problems now not most effective with discovering the right kind sizes to suit its more and more various astronaut corps, but additionally with degradation of a few go well with elements. Now the company is popping to 2 industrial corporations: Axiom House and Collins Aerospace, a subsidiary of Raytheon Applied sciences, to construct and care for its new technology of spacesuits. Underneath the Exploration Extravehicular Job Services and products Contract, or xEVAS, NASA is offering Collins and Axiom, along side quite a lot of their trade companions, with as much as $3.5 billion via 2034. Axiom received the primary $228.5 million contract to design the fits that will probably be used right through NASA’s Artemis moon missions and Collins received the second one $97.2 million contract to design and broaden a brand new technology of fits for the World House Station. Since NASA is buying its fits from Collins and Axion as a provider, the distributors are unfastened to make further fits for non-NASA consumers as smartly

    “The wonderful thing about this contract is the purposeful necessities for those two fits are very, very shut. So at any given time, shall we ask both of the ones contractors to if truth be told get started running at the different what we name platform,” says Lara Kearney, supervisor of NASA’s Extravehicular Job and Human Floor Mobility Program. “We even have what we name an on-ramp clause within the contract, which means that if any other corporate comes into play and they have got the potential to compete, we will if truth be told deliver them directly to the contract and make allowance them to compete on activity orders as smartly.”

    Kearney says the continuing pageant is helping incentivize the contractors to accomplish on value and time table,  and in the long run is helping stay the expense to the federal government down. CNBC were given a behind-the-scenes take a look at the brand new go well with that Collins Aerospace is designing in collaboration with companions ILC Dover and Oceaneering. NASA hopes to make use of this new go well with at the World House Station by means of 2026.

    Watch the video to determine extra.

  • House station corporate Huge, based through billionaire Jed McCaleb, acquires startup Launcher

    The corporate’s first house tug, known as Orbiter SN1, is noticed present process ultimate release arrangements.

    Launcher

    House station corporate Huge introduced on Tuesday it has obtained fellow startup Launcher in a transfer that successfully triples the previous’s headcount and expands its suite of tech and IP.

    “Development an area station is that this complicated endeavor, and you wish to have a large number of other folks to do it,” Huge founder and CEO Jed McCaleb informed CNBC. “Simply getting the engineers that Launcher has will boost up [development].”

    Huge targets to construct human habitats with synthetic gravity, a step extra formidable than the present 0 gravity surroundings of the World House Station, or of alternative non-public stations underway. The Launcher acquisition provides about 80 staff to Huge’s present group of workers of 40 and brings with it the corporate’s Orbiter satellite tv for pc “house tug” and the E-2 liquid rocket engine which are these days in construction.

    “The era that they constructed – a large number of it’s immediately appropriate for what what we are going to do, so we wouldn’t have to head and increase it once more from scratch,” McCaleb stated.

    Join right here to obtain weekly editions of CNBC’s Making an investment in House publication.

    Monetary phrases of the deal weren’t disclosed.

    “I will be able to inform you that our buyers and our workforce are glad; it is a excellent result for each side,” stated Launcher founder Max Haot, who will sign up for Huge as the corporate’s president.

    Headquartered in Lengthy Seashore, California, at a 115,000-square-foot facility, Huge was once stood up ultimate yr through McCaleb, who made his fortune in cryptocurrency. He is price about $2.5 billion in line with Forbes. Earlier than launching Huge, McCaleb first dipped into the gap business in 2021, becoming a member of the board of Firefly Aerospace after an funding via a non-profit he based known as the Astera Institute.

    Founder and CEO Jed McCaleb

    Huge House

    McCaleb and Haot first met ultimate summer time, and Haot spoke to McCaleb about the opportunity of making an investment in Launcher, he informed CNBC. Whilst Haot has constructed Launcher since 2017 “with lower than $30 million of investment,” he stated fundraising was once “certainly one of our largest demanding situations” and the dialogue with McCaleb briefly turned into targeted round M&A.

    “Now we have some distance higher sources because of Jed,” Haot stated.

    Huge and Launcher signed the deal on Nov. 10, and the purchase closed a couple of week in the past.

    The new failure of Launcher’s first Orbiter challenge, which accomplished some goals however was once not able to deploy the a couple of buyer satellites onboard, “did not issue in any respect” within the acquisition procedure, Haot stated.

    The corporate expects to fly the following two Orbiter missions this yr.

    “In the long run, our objective is a station which is larger than what Orbiter is, however a large number of the similar parts and era are what finally end up being flown at the station, so that you roughly want this platform to check it on,” McCaleb stated.

    The World House Station is pictured from SpaceX’s Staff Dragon Endeavour all the way through a fly round on Nov. 8, 2021.

    NASA

    Whilst Launcher was once growing a small rocket known as Gentle, which the E-2 engine was once in trying out for, Huge introduced that the corporate won’t proceed paintings at the rocket. And, even if McCaleb said the E-2 engine isn’t one thing his corporate would have advanced by itself, he stated Launcher has made “a ton of development on that and it sort of feels tremendous treasured, so it is not one thing we would have liked to close down.”

    For now, McCaleb is the only funder of Huge as he pursues a long-term objective of creating house stations with synthetic gravity.

    “One of the most benefits of getting this be self-funded is that we are not beholden – not to simply financial cycles, however simply the whims of buyers usually,” McCaleb stated.

  • FAA desires to fantastic SpaceX $175,000 for failing to post knowledge prior to a release

    A Falcon 9 rocket launches a batch of Starlink satellites to orbit on April 29, 2022.

    SpaceX

    The Federal Aviation Management seeks a $175,000 fantastic towards Elon Musk’s SpaceX, alleging the corporate didn’t post required knowledge forward of a Falcon 9 release final yr.

    The proposed civil penalty comes from a venture wearing Starlink satellites that SpaceX introduced on Aug. 19.

    The FAA says the corporate failed “to post release collision research trajectory knowledge at once to the FAA prior” to the venture, which is needed no less than seven days upfront, according to federal laws.

    “Release collision research trajectory knowledge is used to evaluate the chance of the release automobile colliding with one of the crucial 1000’s of tracked gadgets orbiting the Earth,” the FAA famous in a press free up.

    In its enforcement letter, the FAA famous that the utmost civil penalty for this sort of violation of federal laws is $262,666. The regulator is looking for a decrease quantity after reviewing its investigation into the incident.

    An FAA spokesperson advised CNBC that the company has no longer up to now proposed civil consequences for a rocket operator failing to post knowledge prior to a release, making Friday’s announcement a primary in its laws enforcement.

    The venture used to be one in all 61 launches that SpaceX performed in 2022, which set a brand new annual report for the corporate. It lately launches a venture to orbit on reasonable each and every 4 days because the starting of this yr.

    Join right here to obtain weekly editions of CNBC’s Making an investment in House publication.

    The corporate has 30 days to answer the FAA’s understand. SpaceX didn’t in an instant reply to CNBC’s request for remark at the rate.

  • Astronaut Sen. Kelly touts ‘shocking’ area trade enlargement, requires extra rocket pageant

    Arizona Sen. Mark Kelly speaks at the once a year Business Area Transportation convention on Feb. 9, 2023.

    Michael Sheetz | CNBC

    Arizona Sen. Mark Kelly, who flew to area 4 instances over a 15-year profession as an astronaut, praised the expansion of the gap trade and gave a rallying cry for intensified pageant.

    “One of the developments are in point of fact shocking; this has been an ideal good fortune,” Kelly mentioned, talking at a luncheon right through the Business Area Transportation convention in Washington, D.C., on Thursday.

    Kelly famous that the price of sending satellites, folks and load to orbit is recently “a fragment” of what it used to be when he flew on NASA’s area commute. He added that — whilst the trade’s enlargement is encouraging — corporations development rockets want “to step as much as the plate” and convey extra “new release cars to marketplace sooner and include renewed pageant, now not stifle it.”

    “We’d like extra release cars to proceed to cut back the prices related to getting a payload to orbit,” Kelly mentioned.

    A Falcon Heavy rocket launches the U.S.-67 undertaking on January 15, 2023 from NASA’s Kennedy Area Middle in Florida.

    SpaceX

    Rockets are launching at an remarkable tempo, with 2022 environment a brand new annual document of 87 from the U.S. Maximum of the ones have been via Elon Musk’s SpaceX, which is recently launching each and every 4 days on reasonable, however a number of different corporations are aiming to ramp up the tempo and are debuting new rockets within the coming years — together with Rocket Lab, United Release Alliance, Blue Foundation, Astra, Virgin Orbit, Northrop Grumman, Firefly and ABL.

    Join right here to obtain weekly editions of CNBC’s Making an investment in Area e-newsletter.

    Kelly admitted that, “like perhaps a large number of other folks at NASA and a large number of other folks in Washington” on the flip of the century, he used to be skeptical about depending on non-public corporations for launches.

    “I all the time love to suppose I am the primary individual to confess when I used to be incorrect, and I used to be about this,” Kelly mentioned.

    “The economic area sector is important. It is important to the way forward for the U.S. financial system, and it is important to our management in a foreign country. With out the economic area sector, we would not be capable to get our nationwide safety property into orbit. With out it, whole sectors of the American financial system, from telecom to world transport and navigation, would now not be globally aggressive,” Kelly added.

  • SpaceX effectively take a look at fires Starship booster in ultimate key step sooner than orbital release

    SpaceX take a look at fires engines within the towering rocket booster of its Starship prototype on February 9, 2023.

    Supply: SpaceX

    SpaceX on Thursday take a look at fired 31 of the 33 engines within the towering rocket booster of its Starship prototype, as the corporate prepares to release the rocket to orbit for the primary time.

    Known as a “static fireplace,” the milestone take a look at is the overall main hurdle sooner than SpaceX tries to release the just about 400-foot-tall rocket to house.

    The corporate mentioned in a tweet in a while after the take a look at that the engines on the base of the Tremendous Heavy booster fired for “complete period,” which means the anticipated period of the take a look at.

    CEO Elon Musk mentioned in a next tweet that SpaceX became off one engine sooner than the take a look at and every other engine “stopped itself.”

    “Nonetheless sufficient engines to succeed in orbit!” Musk mentioned.

    Enroll right here to obtain weekly editions of CNBC’s Making an investment in House publication.

    SpaceX has continuously been development as much as the primary flight take a look at of its Starship rocket. President and COO Gwynne Shotwell on Wednesday wired the primary release try can be experimental.

    An aerial view of a Starship prototype stacked on a Tremendous Heavy booster on the corporate’s Starbase facility out of doors of Brownsville, Texas.

    SpaceX

    Starship is designed to hold shipment and other people past Earth and is important to the Nationwide Aeronautics and House Management’s plan to go back astronauts to the moon. SpaceX gained a just about $3 billion contract from the gap company in 2021.

    Whilst SpaceX had was hoping to habits the primary orbital Starship release as early as summer time 2021, delays in growth and regulatory approval have driven again that timeline. SpaceX wishes a license from the Federal Aviation Management as a way to release Starship.

    Shotwell mentioned Wednesday, “I feel we’re going to be in a position to fly proper at the time-frame that we get the license.”

    The corporate will subsequent analyze the results of Thursday’s static fireplace take a look at. Shotwell estimated {that a} a success static would see SpaceX in a position to release the primary Starship orbital flight “inside the subsequent month or so.”

  • Throughout the ‘Wormhole,’ Relativity House’s monster manufacturing facility 3-d-printing reusable rockets

    The outside of “The Wormhole” manufacturing facility.

    Relativity House

    LONG BEACH, California – It was once a couple of days into the brand new 12 months but Relativity House’s manufacturing facility was once anything else however quiet, a din of process with huge 3-d printers buzzing and the clanging of development ringing out.

    Now about 8 years on from its founding, Relativity continues to develop because it pursues a unique means of producing rockets out of most commonly 3-d-printed constructions and portions. Relativity believes that its method will make development orbital-class rockets a lot sooner than conventional strategies, requiring hundreds much less portions and enabling adjustments to be made by means of device — aiming to create rockets from uncooked fabrics in as low as 60 days.

    The corporate has raised over $1.3 billion in capital to this point and continues to increase its footprint, together with the addition of greater than 150 acres at NASA’s rocket engine checking out middle in Mississippi. Relativity was once named to CNBC’s Disruptor 50 final 12 months.

    Join right here to obtain weekly editions of CNBC’s Making an investment in House e-newsletter.

    The corporate’s first rocket, identified Terran 1, is these days within the ultimate levels of preparation for its inaugural release from Cape Canaveral in Florida. That rocket was once inbuilt “The Portal,” the 120,000-square-foot manufacturing facility the corporate inbuilt Lengthy Seaside.

    The interior of “The Wormhole” manufacturing facility in Lengthy Seaside, California.

    Relativity House

    However previous this month CNBC took a glance inside of “The Wormhole:” The greater than one-million sq. foot facility the place Boeing up to now constructed C-17 plane is the place Relativity now’s filling in with equipment and development its better, reusable line of Terran R rockets.

    “I in reality attempted to kill this challenge a number of occasions,” Relativity CEO and co-founder Tim Ellis instructed CNBC, gesturing to probably the most corporate’s latest additive production machines – codenamed “Reaper,” a connection with the StarCraft video games — which marks the fourth era of the corporate’s Stargate printers.

    A closeup take a look at probably the most corporate’s “Reaper” printers at paintings.

    Relativity House

    In contrast to Relativity’s prior Stargate generations, which published vertically, the fourth era ones development the principle constructions of Terran R are printing horizontally. Ellis emphasised the exchange permits its printers to fabricate seven occasions sooner than the 3rd era, and feature been examined at speeds as much as 15 occasions sooner.

    The dimensions of probably the most Stargate “Reaper” printers.

    Relativity House

    “[Printing horizontally] turns out very counterintuitive, nevertheless it finally ends up enabling a definite exchange within the physics of the printhead which is then a lot, a lot sooner,” Ellis stated.

    A couple of the corporate’s “Reaper” 3-d-printers.

    Relativity House

    Thus far, the corporate is using a couple of 3rd of the cavernous former Boeing facility, the place Ellis stated Relativity has room for approximately a dozen printers that may produce Terran R rockets at a tempo of “a number of a 12 months.”

    For 2023, Relativity is enthusiastic about getting Terran 1 to orbit, to turn out its method works, in addition to show how “rapid we will be able to development the additive generation,” Ellis stated.

    “Given the entire financial system, we are clearly being very scrappy nonetheless, and ensuring we are handing over effects,” he added.

    The corporate’s Terran 1 rocket stands on its launchpad at LC-16 in Cape Canaveral, Florida forward of the inaugural release strive.

    Trevor Mahlmann / Relativity House

  • Invoice Gates says Elon Musk’s ambition to colonize Mars isn’t a just right use of cash

    SpaceX CEO Elon Musk speaks throughout the 67th World Astronautical Congress in Guadalajara, Mexico.

    Susana Gonzalez | Bloomberg | Getty Pictures

    Invoice Gates puzzled whether or not Elon Musk’s present priorities would make him a just right philanthropist, taking factor along with his fellow billionaire’s ambition to ship other folks to Mars.

    In an interview with the BBC, set to be broadcast on Friday night time, the Microsoft co-founder used to be requested if he concept Musk would qualify as a philanthropist. Gates spoke back pronouncing he does not suppose Musk is one these days however that this may occasionally exchange in long run.

    “Such things as Tesla are having a good affect, even with out being a type of philanthropy,” Gates mentioned. “I feel some day he’s going to sign up for the rank of philanthropists the usage of his ingenuity,” he added.

    He puzzled the billionaire’s imaginative and prescient of colonizing Mars. Musk’s house exploration challenge, SpaceX, is spending aggressively on spacecraft and rockets within the hope that it’ll at some point ship people to the purple planet.

    Requested by way of BBC journalist Amol Rajan if going to Mars used to be a just right use of cash, Gates mentioned: “Now not personally.”

    He added that investment vaccine construction used to be a greater use of money than hanging other folks on Mars.

    “It is in reality fairly dear to visit Mars,” he mentioned. “You’ll be able to purchase measles vaccines and save lives for one thousand greenbacks consistent with existence stored.”

    “It simply roughly grounds you. Do not move to Mars.”

    Gates and Musk have regularly feuded through the years. In April, Musk mentioned he requested Gates if he used to be short-selling Tesla — in different phrases, having a bet that the cost of the electrical carmaker’s inventory would fall.

    When Gates published in 2020 that he purchased himself an all-electric Porsche Taycan, a Twitter consumer requested: “I’m wondering why Invoice Gates made up our minds to head with the Taycan as an alternative of a Tesla.”

    Musk spoke back in a tweet: “My conversations with Gates were underwhelming tbh [to be honest].”

    Musk has additionally in the past speculated on the potential of Gates shorting his corporate’s inventory. Requested about the ones feedback and whether or not he used to be quick Tesla, Gates instructed CNBC remaining 12 months: “I do not speak about my investments however I feel he will have to be very pleased with what he is accomplished.”

    In a Bloomberg interview additionally in February 2021, Gates mentioned that he wanted he had “been extra at the lengthy facet” of Tesla when requested about Musk’s claims.

    —CNBC’s Joanna Tan contributed to this file