Tag: Russian President

  • Why did Wagner leader elevate pressure in opposition to Putin? What does it imply for Ukraine?

    By means of India Nowadays International Table: The remaining 24 hours were slightly unusual for Russia. The executive of the non-public military referred to as Wagner, Yevgeny Prigozhin, stepped up his feud with Russia’s army best brass on Friday and rejected President Vladimir Putin’s core justification for invading Ukraine.

    He launched a chain of audio recordings on Telegram, accusing Russia’s army management of killing his forces and ordered his troops to march in opposition to Moscow to hunt “revenge”.

    Within the video, the Wagner leader mentioned the “evil” of Russia’s army management “will have to be stopped” and his Wagner mercenary pressure will lead a “march for justice” in opposition to the Russian army.

    On the other hand, the riot perceived to come to an abrupt finish on Saturday, with Prigozhin pronouncing that his troops would go back to base to steer clear of “Russian bloodshed”.

    In an audio message, Prigozhin said that the warring parties can be returning to their base because of the prospective dangers of violence and lack of existence.

    Hours later, the Kremlin on Saturday mentioned the rebellious Russian mercenary commander who ordered his troops to march on Moscow ahead of hastily reversing direction will transfer to neighboring Belarus and no longer face prosecution.

    What does the riot imply for Ukraine?

    Whilst it’s unimaginable to grasp the broader fallout, the riot – although short-lived – is more likely to receive advantages Ukraine.

    Focal point, guns and troops had been shifted clear of the frontlines, as Kyiv intensifies its counter-offensive, The Parent reported.

    Russia’s generals had been pressured to pay attention to occasions at house although the riot used to be short-lived.

    What does it imply past Ukraine?

    Wagner has been a great tool of Russian overseas coverage and gear projection, its troops supporting allies, and offering a caution to these no longer heeding messages from Moscow.

    It’s not going that Putin can in an instant substitute this arm’s-length mercenary pressure, although he chooses to forget about messages from this rebellion.

    The leaders who trusted Wagner give a boost to usually are reassessing their safety.

  • Mercenary Wagner team’s armed revolt in Russia | What we all know thus far

    Via India These days Global Table: Russian President Vladimir Putin on Saturday in a televised cope with warned of a harsh reaction to rebellious Wagner warring parties. With out in particular citing Wagner team boss Yevgeny Prigozhin, Putin stated the top “ambitions” of a few have resulted in “top treason”.

    “What we’re witnessing now could be a stab within the again, they usually should endure the punishment. Our reaction will probably be harsh to this armed revolt. We’d like in Russia the cohesion of all our forces,” the president stated, vowing to punish ‘traitors’.

    Putin stated “armed mutiny” by way of the Wagner Staff mercenary power used to be “treason”, and that anybody who had taken up fingers in opposition to the Russian army can be punished.

    He stated “decisive motion” can be taken to stabilise the placement in Rostov-on-Don.

    FOLLOW LIVE UPDATES ON RUSSIA-UKRAINE BLOG HERE

    WAGNER GROUP TAKES ON RUSSIA

    The remarks of the Russian President got here because the chief of the Wagner non-public army corporate, Yevgeny Prigozhin, introduced that he had entered Russia together with his troops to overthrow the rustic’s army command. Prigozhin claimed that his forces had army amenities in Russia’s southern town of Rostov-on-Don below their keep an eye on.

    “We’re within the (military) headquarters, it’s 7:30 am (0430 GMT),” Prigozhin stated in a video on Telegram. “Army websites in Rostov, together with an aerodrome, are below keep an eye on,” he stated.

    The Wagner team additionally claimed it had taken keep an eye on of Russian army amenities within the Russian town of Voronezh. He stated he and his 25,000 infantrymen had been keen to sacrifice their lives.

    As Wagner warring parties took keep an eye on of army institutions in key Russian towns, the Russian government stepped up safety in numerous areas. The Moscow mayor stated that “anti-terrorism” movements had been being taken within the town.

    ALSO READ | Mutiny in Russia: Mercenary team Wagner enters Russian town of Rostov, Moscow on top alert

    RUSSIA ORDERS WAGNER CHIEF’S ARREST

    Russia’s safety products and services had answered to Prigozhin’s declaration of an armed revolt by way of calling for his arrest.

    In Moscow, vital amenities had been “below bolstered coverage”, the TASS state-run information company reported, bringing up a regulation enforcement supply.

    Russia’s FSB safety had opened a prison case in opposition to Prigozhin for armed mutiny. The FSB safety carrier blamed the Wagner leader for looking to get started a “civil war” and referred to as on Wagner warring parties to seize him.

    WHY AN ARMED REBELLION?

    Prigozhin, whose Wagner defense force spearheaded the seize of the Ukrainian town of Bakhmut closing month, has for months been overtly accusing defence minister Sergei Shoigu and Russia’s most sensible normal, Valery Gerasimov, of rank incompetence and of denying Wagner ammunition and fortify in its battles in Ukraine.

    As their feud gave the impression to come to a head, the ministry issued a commentary announcing Prigozhin’s accusations had been “now not true and are an informational provocation”.

    ALSO READ | Scorching canine vendor to mercenary team head: All about Wagner leader who challenged Putin

    Prigozhin has accused the Russian army of sporting out a perilous missile strike on Wagner troops in Ukraine, a price defence ministry has denied.

    He posted a video during which he says Wagner forces will proceed to blockade town and transfer directly to Moscow until defence chiefs Sergei Shoigu and Valery Gerasimovn meet him, reported the BBC.

    “I ask that no person post any resistance.” In a later Telegram publish, Prigozhin stated that his grievance of the army management used to be a “march of justice” and now not a coup.

    The mercenary chief has more and more put himself at odds with the Kremlin narrative concerning the warfare, whilst caution Russians that complete mobilization and martial regulation are vital to keep away from defeat in Ukraine.

    He additionally accused Russia’s most sensible protection officers of the usage of the warfare to complement themselves and leaving the rustic unprotected following a border incursion by way of attackers who crossed from Ukraine.

    (With inputs from companies)

    ALSO READ | ‘All 25,000 able to die’: mercenary team head, as soon as Putin best friend, activates Russia

  • Mysterious loss of life of Putin-critic Russian pop celebrity Dima Nova sparks row

    But every other mysterious loss of life of a well-known Russian pop celebrity and founding father of the digital track team Cream Soda, Dima Nova has raised eyebrows because of his aversion against Russian President Putin.

    New Delhi ,UPDATED: Mar 23, 2023 18:40 IST

    Russian pop celebrity Dima Nova’s (proper) aversion against President Vladimir Putin (left) turned into extensively obvious after he penned the music “Aqua Disco”.

    Via Bidisha Saha: Including to the incomprehensible record of bizarre deaths of Russian ministers, businessmen and common celebrities who had an aversion against the President Vladimir Putin is 34-year-old singer Dima Nova, whose actual title was once Dmitry Svirgunov. As in line with the reputable maintain of Cream Soda on VK, the singer drowned after falling within the icy waters of the frozen Volga River whilst crossing it on Sunday within the village of Dievo-Gorodishche, in Russia’s Yaroslavl area.

    A Russian information outlet reported that the singer together with his 25-year-old brother Roman Svirgunov, and their 3 different pals have been all drawn underneath the ice via the tough present, and was once to start with regarded as lacking. Even though the 2 other folks were rescued, the pop celebrity was once discovered useless together with one in all his pals who died later, within the ambulance.

    The singer and his fellow manufacturer Ilya Gadayev based Cream Soda in 2012 and feature since then collaborated with different common Russian musicians like Feduk, Alyona Sviridova, Antokha MC, and Alexander Gudkov. The reputable maintain of Cream Soda took to VK, a Russian social media community to announce his loss of life.

    DIMA NOVA’S ANTIPATHY TOWARDS PUTIN

    In line with Moscow Occasions, comic and Kremlin critic Alexander Gudkov used one in all Dima’s music to poke a laugh on the Russian president over his luxurious mansion regarding it as ‘Putin’s Palace’ in 2021.

    Dima’s sentiments of aversion against the Russian President have been extensively common after he penned the anti-Putin music “Aqua Disco” which turned into a well known anthem in opposition to Vladimir Putin. Within the music, he criticised Putin’s reported 1.3 billion buck mansion and was once sung steadily in protests in opposition to Moscow’s invasion of Ukraine.

    Additionally Learn | Russian missiles batter Ukraine, however Bakhmut offensive noticed stalling

    In recent years, the music turned into so common that the protests have been known as ‘aqua disco events’. The band capitalised at the description of the mansion’s hookah front room and a room it sounds as if described as an “aquatic disco,” prompting Cream Soda to write down the music “Aqua Disco” or “akvadiskoteka” as a satire.

    There are a number of movies on social media of other folks from around the nation appearing some protesters brandishing bathroom brushes and chanting, “Aqua disco” – insinuating an $850 bathroom brush and elaborate fountain detailed in ‘Putin’s Palace,’ which was once up to now described in Navalny’s document.

    Additionally Learn | Russia moves Ukrainian towns with missiles, drones as Putin bids farewell to Xi

    The Kremlin has denied the document concerning the palace and previous scrambled to comprise the general public outrage over it. The video known as “Putin’s Palace” from Alexey Navalny YouTube channel garnered over 126 million perspectives. “They’re going to stay on stealing increasingly till they bankrupt all of the nation,” Mr Navalny says within the video, regarding Putin.

    A picture of assets close to Russia’s southern Black Sea that Navalny says is a palace for President Vladimir Putin. Supply: Screenshot from Alexey Navalny Youtube Channel.

    As in line with New York Publish, the lyrics from the music ship a message to Putin: “You might be inviting me to the films and for a few glasses. Inviting me to respire within the shisha smoke, to cool at the covers, to observe the sundown out of your marble boudoir. You simply don’t remember the fact that could be very old-fashioned.”

    THE GRIM STRING OF PAST RUSSIAN DEATHS

    Over the 12 months that went via, there have been loss of life instances reported of commercial tycoons, elites, oligarchs, and different well-known other folks in eerie cases everywhere the arena highlighting the enigma of Russian deaths. The average hyperlink between them was once that all of them have been critics of Vladimir Putin.

    There have been a couple of extensive patterns – falling off home windows, suicide and drowning in a swimming pool or water frame and hasty cremation of our bodies on the behest of the Russian embassy- other folks have been mysteriously losing useless since Putin started his invasion of Ukraine.

    Additionally Learn | Global Financial institution says Ukraine wishes $411 billion for reconstruction and restoration

    Even though it isn’t imaginable to mention if those are mere coincidences or possess some sense of connection because the occurrences have been made to seem like injuries. Alternatively, it has certainly heightened tensions on the Kremlins as other folks at the moment are speculating Putin of silencing his critics. Different critics like Ilya Yashin, Aleksei Navalny have been slapped with heavy prison phrases and steadily narrowly escaped loss of life or exile.

    The band additionally posted footage of Dima Nova and his good friend Kiselev announcing, “Dima and Goshi are not more.”

    Edited Via:

    Raajnandini Mukherjee

    Revealed On:

    Mar 23, 2023

  • ‘No use for that’: Putin guidelines out the usage of nuclear guns towards Ukraine

    Russian President Vladimir Putin on Thursday denied having any intentions of the usage of nuclear guns in Ukraine however described the war there as a part of alleged efforts via the West to protected its world domination, which he insisted are doomed to fail.

    Moscow ,UPDATED: Oct 27, 2022 22:44 IST

    Russian President Vladimir Putin speaks on the plenary consultation of the nineteenth annual assembly of the Valdai Global Dialogue Membership out of doors Moscow on Thursday. (Picture: AP)

    By means of Related Press: Russian President Vladimir Putin on Thursday denied having any intentions of the usage of nuclear guns in Ukraine however described the war there as a part of alleged efforts via the West to protected its world domination, which he insisted are doomed to fail.

    Talking at a convention of global overseas coverage mavens, Putin mentioned it’s useless for Russia to strike Ukraine with nuclear guns. “We see little need for that,” Putin mentioned. “There is not any level in that, neither political, nor army.”

    In a protracted speech filled with diatribes towards the U.S. and its allies, Putin accused the U.S. and its allies of looking to dictate their phrases to different countries in a “bad, bloody and grimy” domination sport.

    Additionally Learn | Iciness is coming: Russia ups the nuclear ante as Ukraine conflict intensifies

    Putin, who despatched his troops into Ukraine on February 24, has forged Western make stronger for Ukraine as a part of extensive efforts via Washington and its allies to implement its will upon others thru what they name a rules-based global order. He argued that the arena has reached a turning level, when “the West is not ready to dictate its will to the humankind however nonetheless tries to do it, and nearly all of countries not wish to tolerate it.”

    The Russian chief claimed that the Western insurance policies will foment extra chaos, including that “he who sows the wind will reap the whirlwind.”

    Putin claimed that “humankind now faces a call: gather a load of issues that can inevitably overwhelm us all or attempt to to find answers that might not be excellent however operating and may make the arena extra solid and protected.”

    Additionally Learn : Russia, Ukraine to move all out for Kherson amid nuclear, ‘grimy bomb’ threats

    The Russian chief mentioned Russia isn’t the enemy of the West however will proceed to oppose the purported diktat of Western neo-liberal elites, accusing them of looking to subdue Russia.

    “Their function is to make Russia extra susceptible and switch it into an tool for gratifying their geopolitical duties, they have got failed to succeed in it and they are going to by no means be triumphant,” Putin mentioned.

    Putin reaffirmed his long-held declare that Russians and Ukrainians are a part of a unmarried other people and once more denigrated Ukraine as an “synthetic state,” which gained ancient Russian lands from Communist rulers all through the Soviet instances.

    The Russian chief repeated Moscow’s unfounded declare that Ukraine was once plotting to detonate a radioactive grimy bomb accountable Russia in a false flag assault, the allegations rejected via Ukraine and pushed aside via its Western allies as “transparently false.”

    Additionally Learn: Kyiv making ready to make use of ‘grimy bomb’ in Ukraine: Rebuffed via western nations, Russia brings topic to UNSC

    Putin mentioned he thinks “always” concerning the casualties Russia has suffered within the Ukraine war, however insisted that NATO’s refusal to rule out potential Ukraine’s club and Kyiv’s refusal to stick to a peace deal for its separatist war within the nation’s east has left Moscow no different selection.

    He denied underestimating Ukraine’s talent to struggle again and insisted that his “particular army operation” has proceeded as deliberate.

    Putin additionally stated the demanding situations posed via Western sanctions, however argued that Russia has confirmed resilient to overseas power and has transform extra united.

    Posted By means of:

    Raajnandini Mukherjee

    Printed On:

    Oct 27, 2022

  • Putin proven in irritating come across with leader of personnel at A ways East struggle video games

    Russian President Vladimir Putin was once proven in a clumsy come across along with his army leader of personnel on Tuesday as he inspected struggle video games in Russia’s A ways East, hundreds of miles from the struggle in Ukraine.

    The Zvezda army information provider revealed video of Putin and leader of personnel Basic Valery Gerasimov coming into an remark sales space, sitting down with a large house between them and keeping up an uncomfortable silence whilst looking forward to Defence Minister Sergei Shoigu to reach.

    Gerasimov stroked his hair and shuffled papers and Putin picked up and peered thru a couple of binoculars, at one level acknowledging a remark from the overall through nodding tersely.

    The awkward frame language drew scrutiny from political and armed forces analysts on social media.

    “Putin clearly doesn’t even wish to communicate with the commander of the Russian defense force,” wrote former Swedish top minister Carl Bildt on Twitter.

    In a separate clip, the temper seemed lighter as Putin and Shoigu have been proven exchanging a shaggy dog story whilst Gerasimov spoke at the telephone.

    Gerasimov has been nearly absent from public view right through the 195 days of Russia’s struggle in Ukraine, prompting hypothesis about his status with Putin or even every now and then about his well being.

    Having captured a couple of 5th of the rustic, Russia has been fought to a digital standstill whilst struggling heavy losses in troops and kit.

    By way of continuing with the four-yearly “Vostok” (East) struggle video games, Putin gave the look to be sending a sign that Russia’s army is in a position to behavior industry as standard regardless of the calls for of the struggle.

    However the defence ministry says the workouts that started on Sept. 1 contain most effective 50,000 troops, a fragment of the 300,000 they mentioned took phase in 2018. Western army analysts say they imagine each figures are exaggerated.

    The manoeuvres have integrated forces from each India and China, although it was once no longer transparent if Putin had noticed troops from the ones international locations in motion.

    On Tuesday the defence ministry launched video of the naval a part of the workout, appearing Russia’s Pacific Fleet working towards launching Kalibr cruise missiles which it mentioned had effectively struck a goal greater than 300 km (185 miles) away.

    On Monday, Russian and Chinese language battle ships practised repelling an enemy air assault the use of air defence artillery methods. Final week warships from the 2 international locations performed anti-ship, anti-air and anti-submarine defence duties within the Sea of Japan, the ministry mentioned.

    Putin and Chinese language chief Xi Jinping declared a “no limits” partnership in February, promising to collaborate extra intently towards the West.

    Russia is the most important provider of army {hardware} to India, which went forward with the workout days after the USA mentioned it had issues about any nation maintaining such manoeuvres with Russia now.

    Moscow says the struggle video games additionally contain army contingents and observers from Algeria, Laos, Mongolia, Nicaragua, Syria and 6 former Soviet republics.

  • Putin guarantees Belarus Iskander-M missiles to counter “competitive” West

    Russia will provide Belarus with Iskander-M missile methods inside of a couple of months, Russian President Vladimir Putin informed a televised assembly with Belarusian President Alexander Lukashenko on Saturday.

    On the assembly, held in St Petersburg, Lukashenko informed Putin that Belarus was once involved via the “competitive”, “confrontational” and “repulsive” insurance policies of its neighbours Lithuania and Poland.

    He requested Putin to lend a hand Belarus mount a “symmetrical reaction” to what he mentioned have been nuclear-armed flights via the U.S.-led NATO alliance close to Belarus’s borders.

    “Minsk should be in a position for anything else, even the usage of severe weaponry to shield our native land from Brest to Vladivostok,” he mentioned, striking Belarus and its shut best friend Russia beneath one umbrella.

    Particularly, he requested for lend a hand to make Belarus’s army airplane nuclear-capable.

    Putin mentioned he noticed no use at this time for a symmetrical reaction, however that Belarus’s Russian-built Su-25 jets may if important be upgraded in Russian factories.

    He did, on the other hand, promise to provide the Iskander-M, a cell guided missile machine codenamed “SS-26 Stone” via NATO, which changed the Soviet “Scud”. Its two guided missiles have a spread of as much as 500 km (300 miles) and will lift typical or nuclear warheads.

    Tensions between Russia and the West have soared since Moscow despatched troops into Ukraine 4 months in the past, alleging amongst different issues that NATO deliberate to confess Ukraine and use it as a platform to threaten Russia.

    Russia’s transfer has no longer handiest prompted a barrage of Western sanctions but additionally brought on Sweden and Russia’s northern neighbour Finland to use to enroll in the Western alliance.

    Prior to now week, Lithuania specifically has infuriated Russia via blockading the transit of products topic to Ecu sanctions travelling throughout its territory from Russia, via Belarus, to Russia’s Baltic exclave of Kaliningrad.

    Russia has termed it a “blockade”, however Lithuania says it impacts only one% of the standard items transit at the course, and that passenger visitors is unaffected.

  • Chinese language President Xi expresses readiness to lend a hand settle Ukraine disaster

    Chinese language President Xi Jinping on Wednesday expressed his readiness to play a “optimistic position” to lend a hand settle the Ukraine disaster, China’s state media reported.

    In a telephonic dialog together with his Russian counterpart Vladimir Putin, Xi mentioned, “All events involved will have to take a accountable stance, thus selling the right kind agreement of the disaster in Ukraine.” “China is ready to stay enjoying its optimistic position,” the Chinese language state-run TV quoted Xi as pronouncing.

    Xi emphasized that China has all the time independently assessed the placement at the foundation of the historic context and the deserves of the problem, and actively promoted global peace and the steadiness of the worldwide financial order, China’s reliable Xinhua information company reported.

    All events must push for a correct agreement of the Ukraine disaster in a accountable means, Xi mentioned, including that China for this function will proceed to play its due position.

    Highest of Categorical PremiumPremiumPremiumPremiumPremium

    Alternatively, it’s not but transparent whether or not Xi has presented to mediate to finish the Russia-Ukraine struggle, dropping Beijing’s previous reluctance to take action.

    China, an in depth best friend of Russia, steadfastly declined to sentence Russia’s invasion of Ukraine ever since Putin introduced a different army operation, which resulted in the US and its allies enforcing sweeping sanctions on Russia and stepping up guns provides to Kiev.

    The Russian-Ukraine warfare changed into a struggle when Moscow introduced a full-scale invasion of Ukraine on February 24.

    For his phase, Putin whilst congratulating China’s outstanding building and achievements below the sturdy management of Xi, expressed Russia’s toughen to the Chinese language president’s new projects, the International Safety Initiative (GSI) and opposes any power to intervene with China’s inside affairs the use of so-called problems like Xinjiang, Hong Kong and Taiwan, amongst others, as an excuse.

    He famous that Russia is able to reinforce multilateral coordination with China with the intention to make optimistic efforts in boosting multipolarisation of the arena, and organising a extra simply and cheap world order, the Xinhua document mentioned.

    All through his dialog with Putin, Xi famous that for the reason that starting of the yr, bilateral members of the family between China and Russia have maintained a legitimate building momentum within the face of world turbulence and transformations.

    The commercial and business cooperation between the 2 nations has made stable growth, Xi mentioned, including that the Heihe-Blagoveshchensk cross-border freeway bridge has opened to site visitors, growing a brand new channel connecting the 2 nations.

    The Chinese language aspect stands able to paintings with the Russian aspect to push for stable and long-term building of sensible bilateral cooperation, Xi mentioned.

    China is prepared to paintings with Russia to proceed supporting each and every different on their respective core pursuits regarding sovereignty and safety, in addition to on their primary considerations, deepening their strategic coordination, and strengthening conversation and coordination in such essential world and regional organisations because the United International locations, the BRICS mechanism and the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation, he mentioned.

    China may be prepared to paintings with Russia to advertise harmony and cooperation amongst rising marketplace nations and creating countries, and push for the improvement of the world order and international governance in opposition to a extra simply and cheap route, Xi added.

  • Russia’s Navalny loses enchantment on terrorist, extremist label

    Imprisoned Russian opposition chief Alexei Navalny on Tuesday misplaced an enchantment contesting the verdict by means of prison officers to label him as “vulnerable to devote crimes of a terrorist or extremist nature.” Navalny, who has been at the back of bars since January 2021, was once first designated by means of the prison government as a flight chance, which implied further assessments and inspections in jail. However in October remaining 12 months officers changed that label with the “terrorist or extremist” one.

    “I used to be anxious they might call for that I kissed portraits of (President Vladimir) Putin and discovered quotes by means of (his most sensible affiliate Dmitry) Medvedev, but it surely wasn’t vital. It’s only that my bunk mattress now has a label that describes me a terrorist,” Navalny, in his same old sardonic topic, commented at the transfer on the time in a social media publish.

    He and his protection group filed an enchantment contesting the label, however a panel of judges within the Russia’s Vladimir area about 100 kilometers (62 miles) east of Moscow on Tuesday rejected the enchantment and dominated to stay the designation in position.

    Navalny, Putin’s fiercest foe, was once arrested in January 2021 upon getting back from Germany, the place he have been improving from nerve-agent poisoning that he blames at the Kremlin, and passed a 2½-year sentence for a parole violation.

    Very best of Categorical PremiumPremiumPremiumPremiumPremium

    In March, Navalny was once sentenced to 9 years in jail on fraud and contempt of courtroom fees that he rejected as politically motivated. The transfer signaled an try by means of the government to stay him at the back of bars for so long as conceivable.

    The brand new sentence adopted a year-long Kremlin crackdown on Navalny’s supporters, different opposition activists and unbiased reporters, by which government seem desperate to stifle all dissent.

    Navalny’s shut buddies have confronted legal fees and left the rustic, and his crew’s political infrastructure — an anti-corruption basis and a national community of regional places of work — has been destroyed after being classified an extremist organisation.

    Navalny and several other of his buddies had been added to Russia’s registry of terrorists and extremists.

  • Zelenskyy asks Putin to satisfy, says ‘I don’t chunk’

    Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy has referred to as for Russian President Vladimir Putin to satisfy him, salting the proposal with sarcasm.

    “Sit down down with me to barter, simply now not at 30 meters,” he stated Thursday, it sounds as if relating to fresh pictures of Putin sitting at one finish of a particularly lengthy desk when he met with French President Emmanuel Macron.

    “I don’t chunk. What are you terrified of?” Zelenskyy stated at a Thursday information convention.

    Zelenskyy stated it was once good to have talks: “Any phrases are extra essential than pictures.”