The World Opinion

Tag: ISRO Espionage Case

  • ISRO espionage case: SC units apart anticipatory bail of 4 former officials; asks HC to believe bail pleas afresh

    By way of Categorical Information Carrier

    NEW DELHI: The Preferrred Court docket on Friday requested the Kerala HC to believe afresh anticipatory bail pleas of former Gujarat DGP RB Sreekumar, two former cops of Kerala, S Vijayan and Thampi S Durga Dutt, and a retired intelligence reputable P S Jayaprakash accused of hatching a conspiracy to border former ISRO scientist Nambi Narayan and others within the ISRO espionage case.

    The retired Kerala Cops S Vijayan and Thampi S Durga Dutt have been a part of the Particular Investigation Staff (SIT) which arrested the scientist.

    The bench led by way of Justice MR Shah whilst environment apart HC’s order requested it to rethink their pleas inside of 4 weeks. It additional granted meantime coverage from arrest to the accused for 5 weeks and until the HC comes to a decision their pleas topic to them cooperating within the investigation.

    Court docket’s order got here in a plea filed by way of CBI difficult Kerala HC’s April 16 order granting them anticipatory bail. HC whilst granting them bail had noticed that issues of the Kerala police at that level concerning the espionage case can’t be stated to be with out foundation.

    “Probably the most paperwork that have been produced for perusal point out that there have been positive suspicious cases pointing against the act of the Scientists within the ISRO and that’s what prompted the officials to continue in opposition to them”, Justice Ashok Menon had famous within the order.

    The Prime Court docket additionally remarked that there used to be “now not even a scintilla of proof” to indicate that the petitioners accused of implicating former ISRO scientist Nambi Narayanan within the espionage case have been influenced by way of overseas components.

    Difficult the bail, the probe company had contended that the HC had granted anticipatory bail at the floor that the topic used to be previous. ASG SV Raju had added that regardless of the offence which used to be dedicated 25 years in the past, most sensible courtroom had directed for registration of FIR and it used to be now not open for the HC to grant bail in this floor. Alternatively, Senior Suggest Kapil Sibal for the then IB officer, argued accused used to be charged for “bailable offences”. He additionally added that there used to be no allegation in opposition to him within the FIR and there used to be no foundation for the probe company to take him into custody.

    Narayanan and 6 others have been accused of promoting secrets and techniques referring to ISRO’s cryogenic programme to girls who have been allegedly spying for Russia, Pakistan’s Inter-Services and products Intelligence and different nations. In 1994, he and two different businessmen have been arrested at the fees of espionage.

    In September 2018, the Preferrred Court docket had held that the prosecution initiated by way of Kerala Police within the 1990’s relating to the ISRO Espionage Case used to be maliciously moved in opposition to the Scientist, inflicting him immense humiliation. On account of this, the Kerala Executive used to be directed to pay repayment of Rs. 50 lac to Narayanan. Additional to this, a three-member committee used to be constituted to probe into the unlawful arrest of Narayanan.

    NEW DELHI: The Preferrred Court docket on Friday requested the Kerala HC to believe afresh anticipatory bail pleas of former Gujarat DGP RB Sreekumar, two former cops of Kerala, S Vijayan and Thampi S Durga Dutt, and a retired intelligence reputable P S Jayaprakash accused of hatching a conspiracy to border former ISRO scientist Nambi Narayan and others within the ISRO espionage case.

    The retired Kerala Cops S Vijayan and Thampi S Durga Dutt have been a part of the Particular Investigation Staff (SIT) which arrested the scientist.

    The bench led by way of Justice MR Shah whilst environment apart HC’s order requested it to rethink their pleas inside of 4 weeks. It additional granted meantime coverage from arrest to the accused for 5 weeks and until the HC comes to a decision their pleas topic to them cooperating within the investigation.

    Court docket’s order got here in a plea filed by way of CBI difficult Kerala HC’s April 16 order granting them anticipatory bail. HC whilst granting them bail had noticed that issues of the Kerala police at that level concerning the espionage case can’t be stated to be with out foundation.

    “Probably the most paperwork that have been produced for perusal point out that there have been positive suspicious cases pointing against the act of the Scientists within the ISRO and that’s what prompted the officials to continue in opposition to them”, Justice Ashok Menon had famous within the order.

    The Prime Court docket additionally remarked that there used to be “now not even a scintilla of proof” to indicate that the petitioners accused of implicating former ISRO scientist Nambi Narayanan within the espionage case have been influenced by way of overseas components.

    Difficult the bail, the probe company had contended that the HC had granted anticipatory bail at the floor that the topic used to be previous. ASG SV Raju had added that regardless of the offence which used to be dedicated 25 years in the past, most sensible courtroom had directed for registration of FIR and it used to be now not open for the HC to grant bail in this floor. Alternatively, Senior Suggest Kapil Sibal for the then IB officer, argued accused used to be charged for “bailable offences”. He additionally added that there used to be no allegation in opposition to him within the FIR and there used to be no foundation for the probe company to take him into custody.

    Narayanan and 6 others have been accused of promoting secrets and techniques referring to ISRO’s cryogenic programme to girls who have been allegedly spying for Russia, Pakistan’s Inter-Services and products Intelligence and different nations. In 1994, he and two different businessmen have been arrested at the fees of espionage.

    In September 2018, the Preferrred Court docket had held that the prosecution initiated by way of Kerala Police within the 1990’s relating to the ISRO Espionage Case used to be maliciously moved in opposition to the Scientist, inflicting him immense humiliation. On account of this, the Kerala Executive used to be directed to pay repayment of Rs. 50 lac to Narayanan. Additional to this, a three-member committee used to be constituted to probe into the unlawful arrest of Narayanan.

  • ISRO espionage case: SC to listen to CBI’s plea in opposition to anticipatory bail granted to former officers on February 25

    Through ANI

    NEW DELHI: The Ideally suited Court docket has posted for February 25 the listening to of the plea of CBI difficult the Kerala Prime Court docket order granting anticipatory bail to 4 individuals in reference to the 1994 ISRO espionage case in terms of the alleged framing of scientist Nambi Narayanan.

    A Bench of Justices AM Khanwilkar and CT Ravikumar adjourned the subject after the investigating company sought 4 weeks’ time to report the affidavit.

    Previous, the apex court docket had issued notices to the accused at the petition of CBI.

    The Kerala Prime Court docket on August 13 final yr had granted anticipatory bail to 4 accused — the previous Gujarat Director-Basic of Police (DGP) RB Sreekumar, two former law enforcement officials of Kerala S Vijayan and Thampi S Durga Dutt, and retired intelligence legit PS Jayaprakash — in reference to the case.Looking for cancellation of anticipatory bail granted them, the CBI had mentioned the grant of anticipatory bail would possibly derail the investigation within the case.

    Further Solicitor Basic AS Raju, showing for CBI, had advised the apex court docket that CBI has present in its probe that some scientists had been tortured and framed within the subject because of which construction of the cryogenic engine used to be hit and this resulted in India’s area programme going again by way of nearly one or 20 years.

    Opposing the bail granted to the accused, Raju had mentioned it is a “very severe subject” and there could also be a bigger conspiracy on the behest of overseas palms which is being investigated.

    The CBI had alleged that there used to be a transparent indication that the accused had been a part of a crew, which had ulterior motives to torpedo the makes an attempt of the Indian House Analysis Organisation (ISRO) for production the cryogenic engine.

    It had registered a case in opposition to 18 individuals for more than a few offences, together with legal conspiracy, in reference to the arrest and detention of former ISRO scientist Nambi Narayanan, who used to be accused of spying in 1994.

    The case pertains to allegations of switch of positive confidential paperwork on India’s area programme to overseas nations by way of two scientists and 4 others, together with two Maldivian ladies.

    CBI had previous given a blank chit to Narayanan and mentioned that the Kerala police had “fabricated” the case. The investigating company said that the era ex-scientist used to be accused to have stolen and offered within the 1994 case didn’t even exist at the moment after which best police officers in Kerala had been answerable for his unlawful arrest.

    On September 14, 2018, the highest court docket had appointed a three-member committee and directed the Kerala executive to present Rs 50 lakh repayment to Narayanan for compelling him to go through immense humiliation.

    Terming the police motion in opposition to Narayanan as a “psycho-pathological remedy”, the highest court docket had additionally mentioned that his liberty and dignity, fundamental to his human rights, had been jeopardised as he used to be taken into custody and, in the end, regardless of the entire glory of the previous, used to be forced to stand “cynical abhorrence”. (ANI)