The World Opinion

Tag: india canada

  • ‘Showing No Interest In De-Escalation…’: Defense Expert Weighs In On India-Canada Diplomatic Fallout | world news

    New Delhi: India and Canada are seeing a fresh wave of diplomatic fallout after Ottawa leveled allegations against Union Home Minister Amit Shah. According to MEA spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal, India summoned ‘a representative from the Canadian High Commission’ and formally expressed protest against the claims made by Canadian Deputy Foreign Affairs Minister David Morrison during a committee session. Amid the deteriorating relationship Defense Expert KP Fabian highlights how both Canada’s handling of the situation shows it has ‘no interest in de-escalation’ just now.

    In an interview with news agency ANI, KP Fabian points out the pathways both nations chose to deliver their sentiments regarding the issue, he said, “You may note that the MEA spokesperson said Canadian High Commission representative. Conventionally, you summon the High Commission, the Ambassador or the CDA.” The defense expert said that the reference to summon a country’s representative holds significance in this case.

    Then he went to draw the pattern Justin Trudeau-led Canadian government is following, Fabian said, “Let us assume, that Canada had good reason to conclude that there was some reason to believe in the likely involvement of the Home Minister of India. If that was the case, the correct thing would have been to talk to India through diplomatic channels rather than rush to the media.”

    The defense expert remarked that this indicates “The current government of Canada is not looking for de-escalation and it is not a good idea.”

    Defense Expert KP Fabian further criticized Canada’s approach to the ongoing diplomatic tensions with India, stating, “I do not see any sign of any interest in de-escalation.” He reiterated MEA’s claim that some Indian consular officials in Canada had been placed under audio-video surveillance, which he condemned as a breach of diplomatic protocol. “It is for Canada to deal with it diplomatically, not subject them to surveillance,” he said, adding that “Canada is acting contrary to diplomatic norms.”

    #WATCH | On India-Canada relations, Defense Expert KP Fabian says, “… You may note that the MEA spokesperson said Canadian High Commission representative. Conventionally, you summon the High Commission, the Ambassador or the CDA. In this case, the reference to the… pic.twitter.com/ff2RFwMCdC — ANI (@ANI) November 3, 2024

    According to a Reuters report, Canada alleged that Union Home Minister Amit Shah was involved in “plots to target Sikh separatists on Canadian soil.”

    Canadian Deputy Foreign Affairs Minister David Morrison, speaking to a parliamentary panel, claimed he informed the Washington Post that “Shah was behind the plots.”

  • India Summons Canadian Envoy Over ‘Baseless’ Claims Against Amit Shah | world news

    India summoned a representative from the Canadian High Commission on Saturday, expressing strong objections to allegations made against Union Home Minister Amit Shah by Ottawa. Ministry of External Affairs spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal said that India has strongly rejected the ‘absurd and baseless’ references made to Shah by Canadian Deputy Minister David Morrison during a committee session.

    “We had summoned the representative of the Canadian High Commission yesterday, a diplomatic note was handed over in reference to the proceedings of the Standing Committee on Public Safety and National Security in Ottawa on October 29, 2024,” Jaiswal said.

    Reiterating Indian government’s view of Canada’s ‘behavioural pattern’ motivated by the ‘political agenda’, Jaiswal said, “The revelation that high Canadian officials deliberately leak unfounded insinuations to the international media as part of a conscious strategy to discredit India and influence other nations only. confirms the view that the government of India has long held about the current Canadian government’s political agenda and behavioral pattern.”

    “Such irresponsible actions will have serious consequences for bilateral ties,” the MEA spokesperson said adding that the Government of India protests such allegations in the ‘strongest terms.’

    #WATCH | MEA Spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal says, “Regarding the latest Canadian target, we summoned the representative of the Canadian High Commission yesterday… It was conveyed in the note that the Government of India protests in the strongest terms to the absurd and baseless… pic. twitter.com/8rJhp9uS9G

    — ANI (@ANI) November 2, 2024

    As reported by Reuters, Canada claimed that Union Home Minister Amit Shah was involved in “plots to target Sikh separatists on Canadian soil.”

    In a statement to a parliamentary panel, Canadian Deputy Foreign Affairs Minister Morrison alleged that he told the Washington Post that “Shah was behind the plots.”

    Meanwhile, the United States responded to Canada’s allegations against Amit Shah on Wednesday, describing them as ‘concerning.’ State Department spokesperson Matthew Miller stated, “The allegations made by the government of Canada are concerning, and we will continue to consult with the Canadian government about those allegations.”

  • US embassy rejects record claiming envoy’s ‘India ties may worsen’ commentary

    The USA embassy in India on Thursday disregarded reviews of ambassador Eric Garcetti announcing that US-India ties will likely be adversely affected because of New Delhi’s diplomatic spat with Canada, announcing that Garcetti was once ” running exhausting each day to deepen the partnership between the folks and governments of the US and India”.

    Previous, a record within the Politico claimed that Eric Garcetti advised his group within the nation that family members between India and america “may worsen for a time” amid India’s diplomatic row with Canada.

    In an reputable remark, america embassy rejected those reviews. It stated: “The USA embassy dismisses those reviews. Ambassador Garcetti is operating exhausting each day to deepen the partnership between the folks and governments of the US and India. As his non-public engagement and public time table demonstrates, Ambassador Garcetti and america Venture to India are running each day to advance the vital, strategic, and consequential partnership we’ve with India.”

    The record additionally quoted an unnamed State Division reputable who stated that Garcetti advised his group that “america would possibly wish to cut back its contacts with Indian officers for an undefined time period”.

    INDIA-CANADA ROW

    Ties between India and Canada had been beneath pressure for the previous few months with New Delhi flagging higher actions and threats through pro-Khalistani components within the North American nation.

    Diplomatic family members took a larger hit after Trudeau’s allegations towards India within the Canadian parliament .

    India has rejected the allegations as “absurd” and “motivated”. It additionally expelled a senior Canadian diplomat in a tit-for-tat transfer after Ottawa expelled an Indian reputable.

    On September 21, India requested Canada to downsize its diplomatic presence within the nation as family members between the 2 international locations plunged to an rock bottom following Ottawa’s allegations towards New Delhi.

    India additionally introduced briefly postponing the issuance of visas to Canadian voters.

    Nijjar was once shot useless through two masked gunmen on June 18 in British Columbia. India designated him a terrorist in 2020.

    Revealed On:

    Oct 5, 2023

  • When there’s no motion…: Canada temple frame member on vandalism in August

    Over a month has handed since a Hindu temple used to be vandalised in Canada’s British Columbia, however there’s no knowledge on what motion has been taken, stated Purushottam Goyal, member of the temple’s managing committee.

    Talking to India Lately, Goyal stated, “When the government take no motion in opposition to violence, it creates an influence that they stand in toughen of the ones spreading violence.”

    The Lakshmi Narayan temple in Surrey, is among the largest and oldest Hindu temples in British Columbia. It used to be vandalised with Khalistani posters on August 12.

    The posters learn, “Canada investigates India’s function in June 18th assassination”. The poster on the door additionally had a photograph of Khalistani terrorist Hardeep Singh Nijjar, who used to be killed outdoor a gurdwara in Surrey by way of two unidentified males.

    Goyal stated that the temple committee had no longer been apprised of the investigation into the incident and of who have been known because the accused at the back of it.

    At the Khalistani motion in Canada, Goyal stated, “Only some other folks toughen the call for for Khalistan, however it isn’t tricky to get 100 or 200 other folks in combination and create a ruckus.”

    He stated that Khalistanis keep watch over two out of 20 gurdwaras in Fraser, however the ones no longer of their keep watch over are afraid to talk in opposition to them.

    “When the Top Commissioner got here right here in March, they (Khalistani separatists) threatened violence or even assaulted individuals who sought after to fulfill the HCI for dinner,” he stated, including that the government didn’t arrest or prevent the ones inflicting violence.

    Significantly, Top Minister Narendra Modi visited the Lakshmi Narayan Temple all the way through his talk over with to Canada in 2015.

    Purushottam Goyal additionally condemned Canadian Top Minister Justin Trudeau’s allegations of Indian govt brokers being inquisitive about Khalistani terrorist Hardeep Singh Nijjar’s killing, and referred to as them “completely irresponsible”.

    Hardeep Singh Nijjar used to be the top of the Guru Nanak Sikh Gurdwara Sahib in Canada’s Surrey.

    Taking a dig at Canadian MP Jagmeet Singh, Goyal stated that he helps the Khalistani motion. “Jagmeet Singh helps the violent Khalistan motion. The Canadian govt is status simplest together with his toughen, and is making such statements.”

    Goyal stated that when the temple used to be vandalised in August, a neighborhood assembly used to be referred to as. Then again, not one of the Canadian MPs and MLAs got here to turn toughen, he stated.

    Revealed On:

    Sep 29, 2023

  • Khalistan motion goes to stick in Canada best: Ex-Canadian minister

    There’s little accept as true with between India and Canada now as Ottawa isn’t particular in condemning Sikh extremists calling for the dismemberment of a pleasant nation, says Ujjal Dosanjh, a former Canadian minister of Indian foundation.

    Ujjal Dosanjh spoke to IndiaToday.in on a spread of topics: from the sliding Indo-Canadian ties, the roots of the Khalistani motion in Canada and why Justin Trudeau’s hobnobbing with Sikh extremists has created accept as true with problems with the Indian govt.

    Ujjal Dosanjh used to be the premier of British Columbia. He used to be additionally a member of parliament from 2004-11 with the Liberal Birthday party, whose present chief is Justin Trudeau. He served because the minister of well being of Canada from 2004-06.

    Dosanjh, a distinguished voice of reasonable Sikhs in Vancouver, used to be attacked via Khalistanis outdoor a carpark in February 1985 after he spoke out towards the extremist components. The assault left him with a damaged hand and 80 stitches on his head. Regardless of this, Dosanjh has remained a harsh critic of the extremist components within the Sikh faith.

    Listed below are some excerpts from the unique dialog with him:

    Q. What do you take into accounts the allegation made via Justin Trudeau towards India and New Delhi’s response to it?

    While you expel a diplomat, the rustic reacts in what is known as a tit-for-tat transfer. Trudeau made a commentary within the Space of Commons, catapulting this factor to a sky-high stage.

    There’s little or no accept as true with on both sides. India does now not accept as true with Trudeau as a result of he has been observed hobnobbing with the Khalistanis ever since his management marketing campaign. One in all his maximum senior advisors and cupboard ministers used to be imagined to had been Khalistanis. He’s now supported in govt via Jagmeet Singh, who’s a recognized Khalistani.

    The opposite reason why India does now not wish to accept as true with Trudeau is as a result of they (participants of the Canadian govt) all the time take shelter below freedom of expression… that everybody has the correct to specific. However for those who imagine India a pleasant nation and a fellow democracy, then you’ve got a duty because the chief of Canada to inform your electorate that glance guys, you’ve got the correct to call for Khalistan however my govt does now not make stronger the dismemberment of a pleasant country. They by no means stated that. In truth, no Canadian flesh presser has stated that.

    Q. And what about India’s function?

    From a global viewpoint, if India has executed this (had a job in Nijjar’s killing), at the same time as Trudeau has given no proof thus far, then it’s improper. You’ll be able to’t move around the border and get other folks assassinated.

    The precise motion for India will have to had been to start up an extradition procedure (for Nijjar) because it did in relation to the younger Sidhu girl who used to be killed in India however her homicide used to be deliberate in Canada. That will had been the best direction in Nijjar’s case as a result of he used to be accused of many stuff via India.

    Alternatively, Narendra Modi isn’t observed as a democrat. He isn’t observed as a pacesetter who acts to give protection to minorities in his personal nation. You then suspect that in all probability Narendra Modi is in a position to doing what Trudeau has accused him of.

    Q. Do you assume Canada has observed essentially the most radical face of Sikh extremism outdoor India?

    Oh sure. There is not any nation the place its electorate had been killed (via Khalistanis) like in relation to Air India Kanishka crisis. No different nation the place an Indian minister used to be made the objective of an assassination plot. Canada is where the place this motion has deeper roots.

    Q. And why is that?

    It is lovely laborious to isolate. However if in case you have a management that’s not ready to inform its electorate that please do not attempt to dismember a pleasant nation and we do not make stronger what you might be doing, then it appears like you might be explicitly supporting them below the garb of freedom of expression which they (participants of the Canadian govt) do. Then it turns into herbal for the motion to take cling and develop.

    Q. In one in all your fresh interviews, you stated the Canadian politicians used to peer the Khalistan war as a ‘brown other folks as opposed to brown other folks’ downside. Please provide an explanation for this a bit of extra.

    Now not best Khalistan. Proper after 1984, violence came about between Khalistanis and the individuals who had been towards them — who informed them ‘let’s now not kill every different, let’s now not do violence in Canada, let’s now not undermine our long run on this nation’. The opposite Canadian politicians did not care, they concept brown guys had been preventing brown guys and it did not have an effect on them. No one did the rest. Till the Air India crisis came about. That is after they (Canadian politicians) aroused from sleep.

    Q. Do you assume the Khalistani motion in Canada will spill over to India?

    I doubt it. The Khalistan motion goes to stick right here in Canada best. While you move to India, whilst you are living in Punjab, you are living with non-Sikhs. They’re your family and friends. They intermarry, they learn about and paintings in combination. The entire anger of 1984 has disappeared through the years.

    While individuals who really feel harm, legitimately or now not, towards India or towards the Indian govt, there’s no therapeutic for them in Canada. They do not are living in combination (with different communities right here). They move to their very own temples, principally Hindus move to temples, Sikhs move to their gurdwaras. There’s little or no mingling between the Hindus and Sikhs, infrequently at marriage ceremony receptions possibly. Other folks do not realise that they’re identical to us, they did not harm us, they aren’t our enemies.

    Q. Why do Sikhs, now not that sizeable a neighborhood, cling such sway in Canadian politics?

    I do not know whether or not they cling the sort of sway in politics. However they appear to have a power with Trudeau higher than that they had with any one else. Trudeau received his management at the energy of participants made in Sikh gurdwaras around the nation. However prior to Trudeau and confidently after him, the Khalistanis confidently may not have such sway.

    I imply the (Sikh) neighborhood having a power is an excellent factor. But when separatist components cling such a power, then it is a downside.

    Q. What is Jagmeet Singh’s function on this?

    I’ve observed movies of Jagmeet Singh years in the past talking at sovereignty meetings on Khalistan. He’s a recognized Khalistani and now he helps Trudeau within the govt.

    Even prior to Jagmeet got here at the scene, Trudeau used to be who he used to be. The one distinction now could be that you’ve got two of them to handle (within the govt).

    Q. How is Justin Trudeau other from his father, Pierre, who additionally rejected the Indian govt’s warnings at the Khalistani risk all through his time period as top minister of Canada?

    There is not any comparability between the 2. Justin Trudeau lacks the political conviction of his father. Trudeau Sr. used to be a legal professional, constitutional pupil, and activist.

    (Justin) Trudeau is extra enamoured via identification politics. It is simple for him to latch onto any little staff that wishes other remedy.

    Q. How do you assume the India-Canada ties are going to form up now? Do you spot any normalisation quickly?

    There is not any accept as true with between the governments. I do not see the governments seeking to normalise issues anytime quickly. I feel it’s going to be best after both Narendra Modi or Justin Trudeau are long past from energy, that reconciliation can be reached between the 2 international locations.

    Q. Do not you assume that expelling a diplomat according to allegations is somewhat far-fetched transfer via Trudeau?

    Trudeau hasn’t shared the proof with any one and it’s not recognized what sort of proof it’s. You’ll be able to criticise him for now not hanging on report any proof, however it’s tough to sentence him for what he did. As a result of if he certainly has the proof, then what he stated is professional, regardless of whether or not he will have to have treated it the way in which he has.

    That is why even Canadians are asking him for proof.

    Q. In India, the federal government’s response to the Canadian High Minister’s allegations has met with cheers. What is your tackle that?

    The issue is that the Indians, who’re satisfied, do not realise the actual sufferers listed below are 98 according to cent of the Indo-Canadians who’re peace-loving. They wish to consult with India for quite a lot of causes, like weddings, beginning and loss of life within the circle of relatives, and promoting or purchasing assets. Now they may be able to’t do it.

    Edited Via:

    Rishabh Sharma

    Revealed On:

    Sep 24, 2023

  • Canada’s Trudeau dropping reputation, was once voted worst high minister in 50 years

    Canadian High Minister Justin Trudeau, who’s below hearth for his allegation of India’s involvement within the killing of Khalistani terrorist Hardeep Singh Nijjar, appears to be dropping his reputation amongst electorate, in line with a contemporary ballot.

    An Ipsos ballot states that 40 in step with cent of Canadians wish to see opposition chief Pierre Poilievre, a Conservative, because the High Minister. If elections are held these days, the ballot says, Poilievre’s Conservatives gets 39 in step with cent of votes. Trudeau, who was once elected in 2015 and leads the Liberal Birthday celebration, will settle with 30 in step with cent of votes, Canada’s International Information reported.

    The Conservatives will shape a majority executive, dislodging the Trudeau-led Liberal minority dispensation if polls are held right now, the ballot says. Election in Canada is scheduled to be held within the fall of 2025.

    In July, a separate survey discovered that Trudeau was once the worst High Minister in over 50 years. Apparently, his father, Pierre Trudeau, who served because the High Minister from 1968 to 1979 and from 1980 to 1984, was once fashionable amongst Canadian electorate, in line with CTV Information.

    SHOULD TRUDEAU WORRY?

    The newest polls come as a being worried signal for Trudeau, who’s accused of being cushy and non-committal about performing in opposition to the Khalistani components, steadily brushing it off as “freedom of expression”.

    Trudeau, who had a reasonably subdued go back and forth to India, had a nerve-racking assembly with High Minister Narendra Modi at the sidelines of the G20 Summit in Delhi previous this month. PM Modi raised his issues to Trudeau over sure “extremist teams” that had been enticing in “anti-India actions” in Canada, in connection with the rise in Khalistani actions within the North American nation during the last few months.

    Then again, Trudeau persevered to stay adamant, pronouncing it was once a “freedom of expression”. It wasn’t sudden that the day Trudeau met PM Modi, a so-called Khalistan referendum was once held in Surrey, British Colombia.

    These days, the Liberals, headed by way of Trudeau, percentage energy with the New Democratic Birthday celebration (NDP) led by way of Indian-origin lawmaker Jagmeet Singh, who is understood to be a Khalistani sympathiser. The NDP has agreed to give a boost to the federal government in self belief issues until the election is subsequent held in fall 2025.

    CANADIAN SIKHS HAIL TRUDEAU

    Whilst Trudeau’s feedback have angered India, they appear to have struck a chord a number of the Canadian Sikhs dwelling in Surrey in British Colombia province, regarded as to be the hotbed of Khalistani actions.

    The Sikh group, the biggest inhabitants in Canada outdoor India, have hailed Trudeau as a “hero” and stated he was once “vocalising” about their problems.

    “We recognize any individual after all vocalising what we’ve been pronouncing for an overly, very very long time,” the Monetary Occasions quoted a group organiser as pronouncing. She didn’t give her title for worry of reprisals.

    “Protection is a big worry at this time for Sikhs, now not simply in Canada, however throughout this international,” she stated.

    WHAT IS THE INDIA-CANADA DIPLOMATIC STANDOFF?

    On Monday, Canadian High Minister Justin Trudeau, in a surprising declare, stated his nation’s intelligence businesses had been investigating what he referred to as a “possible hyperlink” between “brokers of the Indian executive” and the killing of Nijjar. Trudeau referred Nijjar as a “Canadian citizen”.

    New Delhi outrightly rejected the claims as “absurd” and “motivated” and expelled a senior Canadian diplomat in a tit-for-tat transfer to Ottawa’s expulsion of an Indian reputable over the case.

    Nijjar, one in all India’s most-wanted terrorists who carried a money praise of Rs 10 lakh on his head, was once shot useless by way of two unidentified gunmen outdoor a gurdwara in Surrey on June 18. He was once the manager of the Khalistan Tiger Drive (KTF).

    On Thursday, India, in a strongly worded commentary, stated that Canada’s allegations looked to be “politically pushed” and requested the Trudeau executive to return down exhausting on terrorists and anti-India components working from its soil.

    India additionally suspended visa services and products for Canadians, because the diplomatic standoff over Nijjar’s killing driven their ties to an rock bottom.

    Observe the India Lately channel on WhatsApp right here.

    Edited Through:

    Prateek Chakraborty

    Printed On:

    Sep 22, 2023