The World Opinion

Tag: CIC

  • 42 information commissioner posts lie vacant: Document

    Specific Information Carrier

    NEW DELHI: At the same time as 42 of the 165 posts of knowledge commissioners stay vacant on the Central Data Fee (CIC) and its opposite numbers within the states, greater than 4.2 crore RTI packages had been filed and 26 lakh 2nd attraction/court cases had been registered earlier than the watchdog our bodies in 2022, the Transparency Global India’s (TII) newest file unveiled on Tuesday.

    Whilst the vacant posts come with two leader state data commissioners, the state our bodies have a illustration of best 5 % girls data commissioners, the file mentioned, including that the RTI regime used to be “but to evolve to the tempo of era/digitalisation”.

    Mentioning that the implementation of the 2005 RTI Act “has no longer been uniform around the nation”, the file mentioned that the “mindset and tradition among a majority of presidency functionaries and public government continues to be set within the technology of secretive functioning of presidency”.

    The Centre gained essentially the most selection of RTI packages in 2022, at 1.19 crore, with Maharashta a far off 2nd at 86.06 lakh, adopted through Tamil Nadu (36.99 lakh) and Kerala (32.82 lakh). The Tamil Nadu data fee, alternatively, led in receiving essentially the most selection of 2nd appeals and court cases (475,299), adopted through Maharashtra (395,354) and the Central Data Fee (343,506).

    Upon freeing the file, Transparency Global India Director Rama Nath Jha mentioned that “the large pendency of appeals/court cases” used to be mirrored within the reasonable ready duration of 2 years on the data commissions. 

    He added that no longer best had been the commissions “turning into parking loads for retired bureaucrats”, the “informal angle” of PIOs/First Appellate Authority, whilst rejecting RTI packages used to be a “primary problem”.
    TII’s learn about published that best 11 out of 29 data commissions on the central, state and UT degree supply e-filing facility for RTI packages and appeals, of which, best 5 of those had been useful.
    It mentioned that the central executive will have to urgently interfere to toughen procedures on the data commissions.

    NEW DELHI: At the same time as 42 of the 165 posts of knowledge commissioners stay vacant on the Central Data Fee (CIC) and its opposite numbers within the states, greater than 4.2 crore RTI packages had been filed and 26 lakh 2nd attraction/court cases had been registered earlier than the watchdog our bodies in 2022, the Transparency Global India’s (TII) newest file unveiled on Tuesday.

    Whilst the vacant posts come with two leader state data commissioners, the state our bodies have a illustration of best 5 % girls data commissioners, the file mentioned, including that the RTI regime used to be “but to evolve to the tempo of era/digitalisation”.

    Mentioning that the implementation of the 2005 RTI Act “has no longer been uniform around the nation”, the file mentioned that the “mindset and tradition among a majority of presidency functionaries and public government continues to be set within the technology of secretive functioning of presidency”.

    The Centre gained essentially the most selection of RTI packages in 2022, at 1.19 crore, with Maharashta a far off 2nd at 86.06 lakh, adopted through Tamil Nadu (36.99 lakh) and Kerala (32.82 lakh). The Tamil Nadu data fee, alternatively, led in receiving essentially the most selection of 2nd appeals and court cases (475,299), adopted through Maharashtra (395,354) and the Central Data Fee (343,506).

    Upon freeing the file, Transparency Global India Director Rama Nath Jha mentioned that “the large pendency of appeals/court cases” used to be mirrored within the reasonable ready duration of 2 years on the data commissions. 

    He added that no longer best had been the commissions “turning into parking loads for retired bureaucrats”, the “informal angle” of PIOs/First Appellate Authority, whilst rejecting RTI packages used to be a “primary problem”.
    TII’s learn about published that best 11 out of 29 data commissions on the central, state and UT degree supply e-filing facility for RTI packages and appeals, of which, best 5 of those had been useful.
    It mentioned that the central executive will have to urgently interfere to toughen procedures on the data commissions.

  • Details about casualties of Chinese language infantrymen can’t be disclosed: CIC

    Via Categorical Information Carrier

    NEW DELHI: The casualty determine of the Chinese language infantrymen in Galwan Valley conflict two years again between the Chinese language Other people’s Liberation Military troops and the Indian Military soldier can’t be disclosed, informed the Central Data Fee (CIC).

    In its fresh order, the CIC declined to permit a plea looking for to grasp “the casualties to the Chinese language forces, if any, by means of courageous infantrymen of the rustic” inflicted all over the clashes between two forces on June 15, 2020. The CIC is the best appellate frame underneath the Proper to Data (RTI) Act.

    The RTI filed by means of applicant Akhand had additionally sought details about the casualty figures suffered by means of the Indian infantrymen in Galwan.

    Galwan is without doubt one of the a couple of standoff issues the place the Chinese language moved of their forces after a conflict between the troops of all sides on Might 5, 2020. The realm is close to the Line of Precise Regulate (LAC) in Jap Ladakh.   

    The applicant had additionally requested for info at the rehabilitation and ex-gratia paid to the households. As well as, the RTI applicant had sought to grasp from the military if Indian infantrymen are lacking within the Galwan river valley after the conflict and its plans to rescue them.

    The military refused to divulge the ideas because it used to be third-party knowledge and it can’t be shared underneath Segment 8(1) (j) of the Act, which exempts from the disclosure of knowledge which is private in nature.

    The military additionally cited Segment 8(1)(a) of the RTI Act which exempts from the disclosure of knowledge which might prejudicially impact the sovereignty and integrity of India, the protection, strategic, medical or financial pursuits of the state, relation with international state or result in incitement of an offence. The tips on it used to be additionally denied.

    The applicant Akhand argued sooner than the CIC that the subject comes to a bigger public hobby and that the ideas must be supplied to him.

    Data Commissioner Vanaja N Sarna stated, “It’s famous {that a} right kind answer used to be given to the appellant wherein it used to be rightly said that because the knowledge is said to 3rd events, the ideas can’t be supplied underneath segment 8(1)(j) of the RTI Act.”

    “It used to be additionally said that the ideas is delicate in nature and can’t be supplied underneath segment 8(1)(a) of the RTI Act. The Fee is not able to seek out any flaw within the answer, therefore, no reduction may also be given,” she stated.

    The Indian Military had misplaced 20 Indian Military infantrymen within the Galwan conflict and the Chinese language had stated the dying of 5 infantrymen all over the conflict. 

    NEW DELHI: The casualty determine of the Chinese language infantrymen in Galwan Valley conflict two years again between the Chinese language Other people’s Liberation Military troops and the Indian Military soldier can’t be disclosed, informed the Central Data Fee (CIC).

    In its fresh order, the CIC declined to permit a plea looking for to grasp “the casualties to the Chinese language forces, if any, by means of courageous infantrymen of the rustic” inflicted all over the clashes between two forces on June 15, 2020. The CIC is the best appellate frame underneath the Proper to Data (RTI) Act.

    The RTI filed by means of applicant Akhand had additionally sought details about the casualty figures suffered by means of the Indian infantrymen in Galwan.

    Galwan is without doubt one of the a couple of standoff issues the place the Chinese language moved of their forces after a conflict between the troops of all sides on Might 5, 2020. The realm is close to the Line of Precise Regulate (LAC) in Jap Ladakh.   

    The applicant had additionally requested for info at the rehabilitation and ex-gratia paid to the households. As well as, the RTI applicant had sought to grasp from the military if Indian infantrymen are lacking within the Galwan river valley after the conflict and its plans to rescue them.

    The military refused to divulge the ideas because it used to be third-party knowledge and it can’t be shared underneath Segment 8(1) (j) of the Act, which exempts from the disclosure of knowledge which is private in nature.

    The military additionally cited Segment 8(1)(a) of the RTI Act which exempts from the disclosure of knowledge which might prejudicially impact the sovereignty and integrity of India, the protection, strategic, medical or financial pursuits of the state, relation with international state or result in incitement of an offence. The tips on it used to be additionally denied.

    The applicant Akhand argued sooner than the CIC that the subject comes to a bigger public hobby and that the ideas must be supplied to him.

    Data Commissioner Vanaja N Sarna stated, “It’s famous {that a} right kind answer used to be given to the appellant wherein it used to be rightly said that because the knowledge is said to 3rd events, the ideas can’t be supplied underneath segment 8(1)(j) of the RTI Act.”

    “It used to be additionally said that the ideas is delicate in nature and can’t be supplied underneath segment 8(1)(a) of the RTI Act. The Fee is not able to seek out any flaw within the answer, therefore, no reduction may also be given,” she stated.

    The Indian Military had misplaced 20 Indian Military infantrymen within the Galwan conflict and the Chinese language had stated the dying of 5 infantrymen all over the conflict.