Tag: Bihar caste survey

  • OBC politics in for churn after SC nod for Bihar caste survey

    Categorical Information Provider

    NEW DELHI:  With the Ultimate Court docket giving a go-ahead to the newsletter of Bihar caste survey information on Friday, Mandal politics is prone to witness a churning within the run-up to the 2024 basic elections. With Bihar and different Opposition-ruled states enjoying at the entrance foot on caste surveys, the Modi executive’s ambiguous stand on national caste census would possibly dent the celebration’s fortunes on Different Backward Categories (OBCs).

    Bihar’s caste census may have implications nationally and the Central executive should explain its stand, says Rashtriya Janata Dal (RJD) MP Manoj Jha. A caste depend is the desire of the hour to gather clinical information of recent nature, and make a decision the quantum of reservation accordingly, he added.  The ultimate caste census was once achieved in 1931, which estimated the rustic’s OBC inhabitants at 52 in step with cent.

    “We did it in Bihar and that is changing into a part of the nationwide software. The BJP has to wreck its silence at the factor. The Centre can lengthen the caste census out of worry of numbers, however it must be achieved in the end because the Charter promises reservation,” he mentioned. 

    “The ultimate caste-based census in 1931 integrated present-day Bangladesh and Pakistan additionally. When the Mandal Fee advice was once applied, that quantum of reservation was once settled for 27 in step with cent as a result of there was once a sealing of fifty in step with cent,” mentioned Jha, including that states like Odisha and Chhattisgarh have additionally kicked off caste surveys.

    The harsh posturing via Opposition events is prone to put the Modi executive in a place as it’s been dithering at the contentious factor of the caste-based census for figuring out and enumerating the SEBC/OBCs, for a very long time. Whilst OBC votes have contributed some exceptional victories to the BJP within the ultimate decade, the BJP’s retreat from the sooner place on caste census hasn’t long gone down neatly with its allies in states like Uttar Pradesh and  Maharashtra. There’s a feeling a few of the group that its  numerical energy should have grown manifold and is left at the back of in affirmative motion.

    Extra considerably, the Bihar executive’s caste census to enumerate other castes may even result in a realignment of castes past the state. 

    Despite the fact that the Rohini Fee, which seemed into the sub-categorization of OBCs, has submitted its file after 14 extensions, Jha issues out that if the Rohini Fee proposals must be applied, a caste census must be achieved first. 

    “It defies good judgment. We nonetheless don’t have clinical information at the inhabitants of various castes. Even supposing the Rohini fee file is to be applied, information is wanted,” mentioned Jha. In keeping with a 2018 file, 37 p.c of the two,600 communities within the OBC central record have 0 illustration in jobs and institutes. It additionally presentations that most effective 2.68 p.c of reservation has been availed via 994 castes.

    Talking to this newspaper, DMK MP P Wilson mentioned that state governments must be given the ability to habits a caste census within the state. Wilson had moved a non-public member’s invoice in Parliament not easy the switch of the topic of caste census from the concurrent record to the state record. “We shouldn’t be denying alternatives to the backward elegance.  Tamil Nadu was once the primary state to arrange a Backward Fee. The ten p.c reservation to EWS was once given with none survey. In terms of different castes, they want empirical information,” he mentioned.

    Whilst social justice has been the primary plank of Congress in lately held Karnataka elections, former Karnataka Leader Minister Veerappa Moily informed this paper that the state executive will quickly post the caste survey, which was once carried out via CM Siddaramaiah in 2014. “We will be able to quickly post the 2014 information. It’s within the technique of publishing.  The survey has been achieved systematically. It’s the cupboard to make a decision whether or not to replace the knowledge or now not,” he mentioned. 

    NEW DELHI:  With the Ultimate Court docket giving a go-ahead to the newsletter of Bihar caste survey information on Friday, Mandal politics is prone to witness a churning within the run-up to the 2024 basic elections. With Bihar and different Opposition-ruled states enjoying at the entrance foot on caste surveys, the Modi executive’s ambiguous stand on national caste census would possibly dent the celebration’s fortunes on Different Backward Categories (OBCs).

    Bihar’s caste census may have implications nationally and the Central executive should explain its stand, says Rashtriya Janata Dal (RJD) MP Manoj Jha. A caste depend is the desire of the hour to gather clinical information of recent nature, and make a decision the quantum of reservation accordingly, he added.  The ultimate caste census was once achieved in 1931, which estimated the rustic’s OBC inhabitants at 52 in step with cent.

    “We did it in Bihar and that is changing into a part of the nationwide software. The BJP has to wreck its silence at the factor. The Centre can lengthen the caste census out of worry of numbers, however it must be achieved in the end because the Charter promises reservation,” he mentioned. googletag.cmd.push(serve as() googletag.show(‘div-gpt-ad-8052921-2’); );

    “The ultimate caste-based census in 1931 integrated present-day Bangladesh and Pakistan additionally. When the Mandal Fee advice was once applied, that quantum of reservation was once settled for 27 in step with cent as a result of there was once a sealing of fifty in step with cent,” mentioned Jha, including that states like Odisha and Chhattisgarh have additionally kicked off caste surveys.

    The harsh posturing via Opposition events is prone to put the Modi executive in a place as it’s been dithering at the contentious factor of the caste-based census for figuring out and enumerating the SEBC/OBCs, for a very long time. Whilst OBC votes have contributed some exceptional victories to the BJP within the ultimate decade, the BJP’s retreat from the sooner place on caste census hasn’t long gone down neatly with its allies in states like Uttar Pradesh and  Maharashtra. There’s a feeling a few of the group that its  numerical energy should have grown manifold and is left at the back of in affirmative motion.

    Extra considerably, the Bihar executive’s caste census to enumerate other castes may even result in a realignment of castes past the state. 

    Despite the fact that the Rohini Fee, which seemed into the sub-categorization of OBCs, has submitted its file after 14 extensions, Jha issues out that if the Rohini Fee proposals must be applied, a caste census must be achieved first. 

    “It defies good judgment. We nonetheless don’t have clinical information at the inhabitants of various castes. Even supposing the Rohini fee file is to be applied, information is wanted,” mentioned Jha. In keeping with a 2018 file, 37 p.c of the two,600 communities within the OBC central record have 0 illustration in jobs and institutes. It additionally presentations that most effective 2.68 p.c of reservation has been availed via 994 castes.

    Talking to this newspaper, DMK MP P Wilson mentioned that state governments must be given the ability to habits a caste census within the state. Wilson had moved a non-public member’s invoice in Parliament not easy the switch of the topic of caste census from the concurrent record to the state record. “We shouldn’t be denying alternatives to the backward elegance.  Tamil Nadu was once the primary state to arrange a Backward Fee. The ten p.c reservation to EWS was once given with none survey. In terms of different castes, they want empirical information,” he mentioned.

    Whilst social justice has been the primary plank of Congress in lately held Karnataka elections, former Karnataka Leader Minister Veerappa Moily informed this paper that the state executive will quickly post the caste survey, which was once carried out via CM Siddaramaiah in 2014. “We will be able to quickly post the 2014 information. It’s within the technique of publishing.  The survey has been achieved systematically. It’s the cupboard to make a decision whether or not to replace the knowledge or now not,” he mentioned. 

  • Bihar caste survey: SC defers listening to for August 18 on plea difficult Patna HC order

    By way of PTI

    NEW DELHI: The Ultimate Court docket on Monday deferred for August 18 listening to on a plea difficult the Patna Top Court docket’s August 1 order giving the go-ahead for a caste survey in Bihar.

    A bench of Justices Sanjiv Khanna and SVN Bhatti indexed the plea filed by means of NGO ‘Ek Soch Ek Paryas’ on August 18 in conjunction with different pleas filed difficult the similar order of the top courtroom.

    A suggest showing for the petitioner difficult the top courtroom order mentioned that at the day of the top courtroom order on August 1, the state executive had overdue night time issued a notification to finish the caste-based survey inside 3 days.

    The bench mentioned it’ll imagine the whole lot on August 18 and by means of that point the judges can even move during the top courtroom verdict.

    Senior suggest Mukul Rohatgi, additionally showing for the petitioners difficult the top courtroom order, mentioned the route could also be issued to the state not to post the main points of the survey until the pendency of pleas ahead of the courtroom.

    Justice Khanna mentioned that it’ll quantity to an oblique keep at the survey with out even listening to the opposite facet.

    “It is going to be with none utility of thoughts. I do not need to do this. On August 18, we will be able to pay attention all of you and all facets”, Justice Khanna informed Rohatgi.

    On August 7, the highest courtroom refused to stick the Patna Top Court docket’s order giving the go-ahead for a caste survey in Bihar and deferred the listening to on petitions difficult it to August 14.

    But even so the plea filed by means of NGO ‘Ek Soch Ek Paryas’ any other petition has been filed by means of Nalanda resident Akhilesh Kumar, who has contended that the notification issued by means of the state executive for the workout is in opposition to the constitutional mandate.

    Kumar’s petition says in the case of the constitutional mandate, best the Union executive is empowered to behavior a census.

    “Within the provide case, the State of Bihar has sought to usurp the powers of the Union of India by means of simply publishing a notification within the reputable gazette. It’s submitted that the notification dated June 6, 2022, is in opposition to the Constitutional mandate of distribution of powers between the State and the Union legislature as enshrined underneath Article 246 of the Charter learn with Agenda VIIth of the Charter and extremely vires the Census Act, 1948 learn with Census Laws, 1990 and is subsequently void ab initio (for the reason that starting),” Kumar has mentioned in his plea, filed via suggest Barun Kumar Sinha.

    The plea submitted that all of the workout of carrying out a “census” by means of the Bihar executive is with out authority and legislative competence, and reeks of malafide.

    Leader Minister Nitish Kumar has frequently insisted that the state isn’t carrying out a caste census however best gathering knowledge associated with folks’s financial standing and their caste so explicit steps might be taken by means of the federal government to serve them higher.

    The top courtroom had mentioned in its 101-page verdict, “We discover the motion of the state to be completely legitimate, initiated with due competence with the professional purpose of offering construction with justice.”

    An afternoon after the top courtroom held the caste survey as “legitimate”, the state executive swung into motion and suspended all ongoing coaching programmes for lecturers so they may be able to be engaged for early crowning glory of the workout.

    The primary segment of the workout was once finished on January 21.

    Round 15,000 officers, together with enumerators and observers, were assigned quite a lot of duties for the door-to-door survey.

    The state executive will spend Rs 500 crore from its contingency fund for the workout.

    NEW DELHI: The Ultimate Court docket on Monday deferred for August 18 listening to on a plea difficult the Patna Top Court docket’s August 1 order giving the go-ahead for a caste survey in Bihar.

    A bench of Justices Sanjiv Khanna and SVN Bhatti indexed the plea filed by means of NGO ‘Ek Soch Ek Paryas’ on August 18 in conjunction with different pleas filed difficult the similar order of the top courtroom.

    A suggest showing for the petitioner difficult the top courtroom order mentioned that at the day of the top courtroom order on August 1, the state executive had overdue night time issued a notification to finish the caste-based survey inside 3 days.googletag.cmd.push(serve as() googletag.show(‘div-gpt-ad-8052921-2’); );

    The bench mentioned it’ll imagine the whole lot on August 18 and by means of that point the judges can even move during the top courtroom verdict.

    Senior suggest Mukul Rohatgi, additionally showing for the petitioners difficult the top courtroom order, mentioned the route could also be issued to the state not to post the main points of the survey until the pendency of pleas ahead of the courtroom.

    Justice Khanna mentioned that it’ll quantity to an oblique keep at the survey with out even listening to the opposite facet.

    “It is going to be with none utility of thoughts. I do not need to do this. On August 18, we will be able to pay attention all of you and all facets”, Justice Khanna informed Rohatgi.

    On August 7, the highest courtroom refused to stick the Patna Top Court docket’s order giving the go-ahead for a caste survey in Bihar and deferred the listening to on petitions difficult it to August 14.

    But even so the plea filed by means of NGO ‘Ek Soch Ek Paryas’ any other petition has been filed by means of Nalanda resident Akhilesh Kumar, who has contended that the notification issued by means of the state executive for the workout is in opposition to the constitutional mandate.

    Kumar’s petition says in the case of the constitutional mandate, best the Union executive is empowered to behavior a census.

    “Within the provide case, the State of Bihar has sought to usurp the powers of the Union of India by means of simply publishing a notification within the reputable gazette. It’s submitted that the notification dated June 6, 2022, is in opposition to the Constitutional mandate of distribution of powers between the State and the Union legislature as enshrined underneath Article 246 of the Charter learn with Agenda VIIth of the Charter and extremely vires the Census Act, 1948 learn with Census Laws, 1990 and is subsequently void ab initio (for the reason that starting),” Kumar has mentioned in his plea, filed via suggest Barun Kumar Sinha.

    The plea submitted that all of the workout of carrying out a “census” by means of the Bihar executive is with out authority and legislative competence, and reeks of malafide.

    Leader Minister Nitish Kumar has frequently insisted that the state isn’t carrying out a caste census however best gathering knowledge associated with folks’s financial standing and their caste so explicit steps might be taken by means of the federal government to serve them higher.

    The top courtroom had mentioned in its 101-page verdict, “We discover the motion of the state to be completely legitimate, initiated with due competence with the professional purpose of offering construction with justice.”

    An afternoon after the top courtroom held the caste survey as “legitimate”, the state executive swung into motion and suspended all ongoing coaching programmes for lecturers so they may be able to be engaged for early crowning glory of the workout.

    The primary segment of the workout was once finished on January 21.

    Round 15,000 officers, together with enumerators and observers, were assigned quite a lot of duties for the door-to-door survey.

    The state executive will spend Rs 500 crore from its contingency fund for the workout.