The World Opinion

Tag: 2002 Gujarat riots

  • ‘Setalvad used to be a part of conspiracy to border then-Gujarat CM Modi in 2002 riots circumstances’, claims SIT 

    Via PTI

    AHMEDABAD: Social activist Teesta Setalvad used to be a part of a bigger conspiracy to border the then-Gujarat Leader Minister Narendra Modi and others as accused within the post-Godhra riots circumstances, and tried to destabilize the BJP executive the use of finances amassed within the title of sufferers, a state SIT instructed a court docket on Wednesday.

    Setalvad used to be arrested closing month through the Ahmedabad crime department at the side of former DGP RB Sreekumar and ex-IPS officer Sanjiv Bhatt for allegedly fabricating proof to border blameless individuals within the 2002 riots circumstances.

    The Mumbai-based activist, these days in prison in Gujarat, has sought bail.

    A distinct investigation crew (SIT) of the Gujarat police, probing the fees towards Setalvad and the 2 former cops, has antagonistic her bail plea.

    Arguing towards the bail plea of Setalvad, particular public prosecutor (SPP) Mitesh Amin instructed the court docket of periods pass judgement on DD Thakkar in Ahmedabad that she used to be a part of a bigger conspiracy to border the then-chief minister Modi and others as accused within the riots circumstances.

    Amin instructed the court docket Setalvad gained finances at the floor they had been supposed to be dispensed some of the sufferers of the 2002 riots, however the cash by no means reached the supposed beneficiaries.

    The SPP claimed the cash by no means reached the sufferers, and it used to be slightly used to destabilise the then-BJP executive and display it engineered and backed the riots, which have been brought on after a mob torched a trainer of the Sabarmati Specific teach close to Godhra station on February 27, 2002, resulting in the dying of 59 passengers.

    The conspiracy concerned Congress leaders just like the past due Ahmed Patel and others, and all this used to be accomplished on the behest of the opposition celebration, he mentioned.

    Additional arguments will proceed on Thursday.

    The court docket is listening to the bail pleas of each Setalvad and Sreekumar.

    They have got already refuted all of the fees levelled towards them and claimed there used to be no advantage in them.

    READ HERE | Chimanlal Setalvad didn’t give blank chit to Gen Dyer for Jallianwala Bagh bloodbath: Historians

    Setalvad, at the side of Sreekumar and Bhatt, used to be booked underneath Indian Penal Code (IPC) sections 468 (forgery) and 194 (giving or fabricating false proof with intent to obtain conviction for capital offence), amongst different offences after arrest.

    The SIT, in its affidavit submitted ahead of the court docket closing week, had accused Setalvad of conspiring with the 2 different accused — Sreekumar and Bhatt — for “dismissal or destabilisation of the elected executive in Gujarat someway.

    ” Opposing her bail plea, the SIT mentioned within the affidavit that the conspiracy used to be performed on the behest of past due Patel.

    At Patel’s behest, Setalvad gained Rs 30 lakh after the post-Godhra riots, the probe crew alleged.

    Setalvad used to fulfill the leaders of a “distinguished nationwide celebration in energy at the moment in Delhi to implicate names of senior leaders of the BJP executive in rebel circumstances”, the SIT additional claimed within the affidavit.

    Final month, the Superb Court docket had disregarded a plea filed through Zakia Jafri, whose husband Ehsan Jafri, a former Congress MP Ehsan Jafri, killed all the way through the riots in Ahmedabad.

    The plea alleged a “better conspiracy” in the back of the 2002 riots in Gujarat.

    However the court docket upheld a prior SIT’s blank chit to Modi (who used to be Gujarat CM from 2001 to 2014) and 63 others.

    The apex court docket had mentioned there’s no “identify of subject material” to give a boost to the allegation that the communal violence that came about after the Godhra teach burning incident used to be a “pre-planned tournament” owing to a conspiracy hatched on the best possible stage within the state.

    Ehsan Jafri used to be some of the 68 folks killed at Ahmedabad’s Gulberg Society all the way through the violence on February 28, 2002, an afternoon after the Godhra teach burning incident.

    The central executive had knowledgeable the Rajya Sabha in Might 2005 that 790 Muslims and 254 Hindus had been killed within the statewide riots.

    AHMEDABAD: Social activist Teesta Setalvad used to be a part of a bigger conspiracy to border the then-Gujarat Leader Minister Narendra Modi and others as accused within the post-Godhra riots circumstances, and tried to destabilize the BJP executive the use of finances amassed within the title of sufferers, a state SIT instructed a court docket on Wednesday.

    Setalvad used to be arrested closing month through the Ahmedabad crime department at the side of former DGP RB Sreekumar and ex-IPS officer Sanjiv Bhatt for allegedly fabricating proof to border blameless individuals within the 2002 riots circumstances.

    The Mumbai-based activist, these days in prison in Gujarat, has sought bail.

    A distinct investigation crew (SIT) of the Gujarat police, probing the fees towards Setalvad and the 2 former cops, has antagonistic her bail plea.

    Arguing towards the bail plea of Setalvad, particular public prosecutor (SPP) Mitesh Amin instructed the court docket of periods pass judgement on DD Thakkar in Ahmedabad that she used to be a part of a bigger conspiracy to border the then-chief minister Modi and others as accused within the riots circumstances.

    Amin instructed the court docket Setalvad gained finances at the floor they had been supposed to be dispensed some of the sufferers of the 2002 riots, however the cash by no means reached the supposed beneficiaries.

    The SPP claimed the cash by no means reached the sufferers, and it used to be slightly used to destabilise the then-BJP executive and display it engineered and backed the riots, which have been brought on after a mob torched a trainer of the Sabarmati Specific teach close to Godhra station on February 27, 2002, resulting in the dying of 59 passengers.

    The conspiracy concerned Congress leaders just like the past due Ahmed Patel and others, and all this used to be accomplished on the behest of the opposition celebration, he mentioned.

    Additional arguments will proceed on Thursday.

    The court docket is listening to the bail pleas of each Setalvad and Sreekumar.

    They have got already refuted all of the fees levelled towards them and claimed there used to be no advantage in them.

    READ HERE | Chimanlal Setalvad didn’t give blank chit to Gen Dyer for Jallianwala Bagh bloodbath: Historians

    Setalvad, at the side of Sreekumar and Bhatt, used to be booked underneath Indian Penal Code (IPC) sections 468 (forgery) and 194 (giving or fabricating false proof with intent to obtain conviction for capital offence), amongst different offences after arrest.

    The SIT, in its affidavit submitted ahead of the court docket closing week, had accused Setalvad of conspiring with the 2 different accused — Sreekumar and Bhatt — for “dismissal or destabilisation of the elected executive in Gujarat someway.

    ” Opposing her bail plea, the SIT mentioned within the affidavit that the conspiracy used to be performed on the behest of past due Patel.

    At Patel’s behest, Setalvad gained Rs 30 lakh after the post-Godhra riots, the probe crew alleged.

    Setalvad used to fulfill the leaders of a “distinguished nationwide celebration in energy at the moment in Delhi to implicate names of senior leaders of the BJP executive in rebel circumstances”, the SIT additional claimed within the affidavit.

    Final month, the Superb Court docket had disregarded a plea filed through Zakia Jafri, whose husband Ehsan Jafri, a former Congress MP Ehsan Jafri, killed all the way through the riots in Ahmedabad.

    The plea alleged a “better conspiracy” in the back of the 2002 riots in Gujarat.

    However the court docket upheld a prior SIT’s blank chit to Modi (who used to be Gujarat CM from 2001 to 2014) and 63 others.

    The apex court docket had mentioned there’s no “identify of subject material” to give a boost to the allegation that the communal violence that came about after the Godhra teach burning incident used to be a “pre-planned tournament” owing to a conspiracy hatched on the best possible stage within the state.

    Ehsan Jafri used to be some of the 68 folks killed at Ahmedabad’s Gulberg Society all the way through the violence on February 28, 2002, an afternoon after the Godhra teach burning incident.

    The central executive had knowledgeable the Rajya Sabha in Might 2005 that 790 Muslims and 254 Hindus had been killed within the statewide riots.

  • 2002 Gujarat riots: SIT’s fees in opposition to Ahmed Patel a part of PM Modi’s technique ‘to absolve himself of duty’, says Congress

    Via Businesses

    NEW DELHI: The Congress on Saturday disregarded as “mischievous and manufactured”, Gujarat police SIT’s fees that its chief Ahmed Patel had financed civil rights activist Teesta Setalvad and hatched a conspiracy to dislodge the then Leader Minister Narendra Modi-led state govt.

    “This is a part of the High Minister’s systematic technique to absolve himself of any duty for the communal carnage unleashed when he was once leader minister of Gujarat in 2002. It was once his unwillingness and disability to keep an eye on this carnage that had led the-then High Minister of India Atal Bihari Vajpayee to remind the manager minister of his ‘rajdharma’,” Congress Basic Secretary Jairam Ramesh stated.

    The remark stated that that is High Minister’s political vendetta system which doesn’t even spare the departed who had been his political adversaries.

    “This SIT is dancing to the music of its political grasp and can sit down anyplace it’s informed to. We know the way an previous SIT leader was once rewarded with a diplomatic task after he had given a ‘blank chit’ to the manager minister,” Jairam stated.

    He stated giving judgment via press, in an ongoing judicial procedure, via puppet investigative companies who trumpet wild allegations as intended findings, has been the hallmark of the Modi-Shah duo’s techniques for years.

    “That is not anything however any other instance of the similar, with the added object of vilifying a deceased particular person since he’s clearly not able and unavailable to refute such brazen lies.”

    Setalvad has been arrested, along side former IPS officials R B Sreekumar and Sanjiv Bhatt, for allegedly fabricating proof to border blameless folks within the Gujarat riots case.

    Mentioning the statements of a witness, the SIT HAD stated the conspiracy was once performed on the behest of overdue Ahmed Patel. At Patel’s behest, Setalvad gained Rs 30 lakh after post-Godhra riots in 2002, it alleged.

    Setalvad used to satisfy the leaders of a “distinguished nationwide birthday party in energy at the moment in Delhi to implicate names of senior leaders of the BJP govt in rise up instances,” the SIT additional claimed.

    It cited any other witness to assert that Setalvad in 2006 had requested a Congress chief why the birthday party was once giving “likelihood to simply Shabana and Javed” and now not making her a member of the Rajya Sabha.

    Closing month, the Preferrred Courtroom disregarded the plea filed via Zakia Jafri, widow of former Congress MP Ehsan Jafri, difficult the blank chit given via the Particular Investigation Staff (SIT) to then Leader Minister Narendra Modi and several other others within the 2002 Gujarat riots.

    Ehsan Jafri was once amongst 69 folks killed all through violence on the Gulbarg Society in Ahmedabad on February 28, 2002. His widow Zakia Jafri challenged the SIT’s blank chit to 64 folks together with Narendra Modi who was once Leader Minister of Gujarat on the time.

    After 58 pilgrims had been burnt alive at the Sabarmati Specific educate at Gujarat’s Godhra Railway Station on February 27, 2002, riots broke out around the state during which greater than 1,000 folks had been killed. (ANI)

    ALSO READ | Pinarayi flays Congress’ ‘silence’ on arrests of RB Sreekumar, Teesta Setalvad

    (With on-line table inputs)

    NEW DELHI: The Congress on Saturday disregarded as “mischievous and manufactured”, Gujarat police SIT’s fees that its chief Ahmed Patel had financed civil rights activist Teesta Setalvad and hatched a conspiracy to dislodge the then Leader Minister Narendra Modi-led state govt.

    “This is a part of the High Minister’s systematic technique to absolve himself of any duty for the communal carnage unleashed when he was once leader minister of Gujarat in 2002. It was once his unwillingness and disability to keep an eye on this carnage that had led the-then High Minister of India Atal Bihari Vajpayee to remind the manager minister of his ‘rajdharma’,” Congress Basic Secretary Jairam Ramesh stated.

    The remark stated that that is High Minister’s political vendetta system which doesn’t even spare the departed who had been his political adversaries.

    “This SIT is dancing to the music of its political grasp and can sit down anyplace it’s informed to. We know the way an previous SIT leader was once rewarded with a diplomatic task after he had given a ‘blank chit’ to the manager minister,” Jairam stated.

    He stated giving judgment via press, in an ongoing judicial procedure, via puppet investigative companies who trumpet wild allegations as intended findings, has been the hallmark of the Modi-Shah duo’s techniques for years.

    “That is not anything however any other instance of the similar, with the added object of vilifying a deceased particular person since he’s clearly not able and unavailable to refute such brazen lies.”

    Setalvad has been arrested, along side former IPS officials R B Sreekumar and Sanjiv Bhatt, for allegedly fabricating proof to border blameless folks within the Gujarat riots case.

    Mentioning the statements of a witness, the SIT HAD stated the conspiracy was once performed on the behest of overdue Ahmed Patel. At Patel’s behest, Setalvad gained Rs 30 lakh after post-Godhra riots in 2002, it alleged.

    Setalvad used to satisfy the leaders of a “distinguished nationwide birthday party in energy at the moment in Delhi to implicate names of senior leaders of the BJP govt in rise up instances,” the SIT additional claimed.

    It cited any other witness to assert that Setalvad in 2006 had requested a Congress chief why the birthday party was once giving “likelihood to simply Shabana and Javed” and now not making her a member of the Rajya Sabha.

    Closing month, the Preferrred Courtroom disregarded the plea filed via Zakia Jafri, widow of former Congress MP Ehsan Jafri, difficult the blank chit given via the Particular Investigation Staff (SIT) to then Leader Minister Narendra Modi and several other others within the 2002 Gujarat riots.

    Ehsan Jafri was once amongst 69 folks killed all through violence on the Gulbarg Society in Ahmedabad on February 28, 2002. His widow Zakia Jafri challenged the SIT’s blank chit to 64 folks together with Narendra Modi who was once Leader Minister of Gujarat on the time.

    After 58 pilgrims had been burnt alive at the Sabarmati Specific educate at Gujarat’s Godhra Railway Station on February 27, 2002, riots broke out around the state during which greater than 1,000 folks had been killed. (ANI)

    ALSO READ | Pinarayi flays Congress’ ‘silence’ on arrests of RB Sreekumar, Teesta Setalvad

    (With on-line table inputs)

  • ‘Will CM, executive be by no means held responsible even though….’ Congress on 2002 Gujarat riots verdict

    By means of PTI

    NEW DELHI: The Congress on Saturday requested if a major minister or a state executive will ever be held responsible even though the state is thrown right into a circle of pre-meditated violence and riots, an afternoon after the Preferrred Courtroom upheld an SIT blank chit to then Gujarat CM Narendra Modi within the 2002 riots case.

    The celebration stated the Preferrred Courtroom verdicts will have to now not be politicised however requested if it is just the collector or law enforcement officials who’re chargeable for any insurrection of their jurisdictions and now not their political masters. “Will Leader Minister, Cupboard & State Government be by no means held responsible, even though the State is thrown right into a circle of pre-meditated violence and riots?” requested Congress basic secretary Randeep Surjewala.

    His remarks thru a chain of tweets got here an afternoon after the Preferrred Courtroom Friday upheld the Particular Investigation Workforce’s blank chit to Modi and 63 others within the 2002 communal riots within the state. “Is accountability simplest of the Collector and deputy commissioner of Police and now not of political government? What then is the Constitutional and ethical accountability of Leader minister and the state executive?” Surjewala requested.

    The legislation in “New India” -:

    Failure to prevent or inactivity to behave towards the ones committing violence isn’t actionable floor towards State Government.
    To behave upon Intelligence inputs is immaterial.
    1/n https://t.co/XYeHUZl4aI

    — Randeep Singh Surjewala (@rssurjewala) June 25, 2022

    The legislation on this “New India” is, he stated, “Failure to prevent or inactivity to behave towards the ones committing violence isn’t actionable floor towards State Govt. To behave upon Intelligence inputs is immaterial. Was once Preferrred Courtroom proper then in pronouncing – ‘As Rome burnt, Nero fiddled’ or is it at the moment? Is failure or inactivity not actionable in legislation? Let the country suppose.”

    Congress spokesperson Abhishek Singhvi stated, “The selections of the Preferrred Courtroom will have to by no means be politicised.” He stated that the Preferrred Courtroom upheld the SIT’s blank chit, in line with which there was once no conspiracy and the violence was once a herbal response.

    “One will have to now not disregard many convicts of homicide in Gujarat riots, on whom the guilt was once proved. The Preferrred Courtroom denies conspiracy or observation by way of the High Minister within the absence of sure law enforcement officials. It will have to merely be revered as an order of the Preferrred Courtroom,” he stated.

    The Preferrred Courtroom on Friday upheld the SIT’s blank chit to the then Gujarat leader minister Narendra Modi and 63 others within the 2002 communal riots within the state, pronouncing there is not any tittle of subject material to turn the violence after the Godhra educate carnage was once pre-planned” owing to the legal conspiracy allegedly hatched on the “best stage” within the state.

    Staring at that inactivity or failure of a few officers of 1 phase of the management can’t be the root to readily infer a pre-planned legal conspiracy by way of the government or to time period it as a state-sponsored crime towards the minority neighborhood, the court docket disregarded a plea by way of slain Congress chief Ehsan Jafri’s spouse Zakia, terming it as “devoid of deserves”.

    Bringing the curtains down at the bid to reopen the probe into the 2002 riots, a bench headed by way of Justice A M Khanwilkar additionally spoke of the devious stratagem to stay the pot boiling, clearly, for ulterior design, and stated disgruntled officials of the Gujarat executive wish to be within the dock and proceeded with in response to legislation for making a sensation by way of making false revelations.

    Alleging a bigger conspiracy in the back of the mass violence towards Muslims, Zakia had challenged the Gujarat Top Courtroom’s October 5, 2017 order rejecting her petition towards the discovering of the Preferrred Courtroom-appointed Particular Investigation Workforce (SIT).