In a significant ruling that has gripped the Tamil film industry, the Supreme Court on Friday declined to grant interim relief to the makers of the upcoming movie ‘Jana Nayakan’. The controversy centers around allegations of title infringement, with producers claiming the name encroaches on an existing film’s rights.
The apex court bench, comprising Justices Hima Kohli and Sanjay Karol, heard urgent pleas from the filmmakers seeking a stay on Madras High Court proceedings. However, the justices firmly refused, directing all parties to approach the Madras High Court for resolution. ‘Let the High Court decide on merits,’ the bench observed, emphasizing judicial hierarchy.
Background to the dispute reveals a clash between two production houses. The original ‘Jana Nayak’ film, released years ago, holds registered trademark rights over the title. The new project’s team argued for creative freedom, but the court remained unmoved, prioritizing established IP protections.
This decision underscores the Supreme Court’s cautious approach to entertainment disputes, avoiding interference in lower court matters unless exceptional circumstances arise. Filmmakers now face mounting pressure as the Madras High Court hearing looms, potentially delaying the much-anticipated release.