A contentious message, alleging that Turkey of betraying India and supporting Pakistan over the problem of ‘Jammu and Kashmir’ after India prolonged humanitarian aide following the devastating earthquake has been doing the rounds of the web.
“Breaking! Turkey helps Pakistan on #Kashmir. Says ‘India has been doing Human rise up violations in Kashmir. India performed Challenge Dost & despatched NDRF staff, aid subject material to Turkey. However in go back Turkey betrayed India & supported Pak in UNHRC. Muslim Ummah wins, Modi failed,” a viral WhatsApp message learn.
Screengrab of the deceptive Whatsapp message
And whilst Turkey has certainly taken stand for Pakistan over Kashmir factor, the above message is deceptive.
The Commentary of Turkey in UNHRC
Turkey has supported Pakistan up to now or even engaged in anti-India propaganda by means of internationalising the ‘Kashmir factor’. Then again, the transcontinental country has now not made this sort of remark within the aftermath of the devastating earthquake on the UNHRC.
On February 27 this yr, the Deputy Minister for Overseas Affairs of Turkey, Mehmet Kemal Bozay, spoke on the United International locations Human Rights Council and thanked the arena for his or her persisted make stronger of the rustic on the time of disaster.
Turkey additionally expressed its dedication to the territorial integrity and sovereignty of Ukraine, the disputed Palestinian State and Crimea. It referred to as upon the international locations to give protection to Afghanistan, migrants and refugees in Syria and the Mediterranean.
Having stated that, Bozay didn’t make any connection with Jammu and Kashmir in his deal with. The remarks of the Deputy Minister for Overseas Affairs of Turkey are reproduced of their entirety underneath:
MEHMET KEMAL BOZAY, Deputy Minister of Overseas Affairs of Türkiye, stated the Turkish country mourned its losses following the most important herbal crisis of this century; 40,000 lives were misplaced and 100,000 other folks injured. Türkiye expressed deep gratitude for the profound world unity won, which reconfirmed that the world group will have to undertake a “one humanity one international” manner in tackling issues. Türkiye would proceed to interact with the Human Rights Council for the security and promotion of human rights for all, and used to be dedicated to Ukraine’s territorial integrity and sovereignty, together with Crimea, and to a simply peace.
Pushbacks and systemic violations of rights of migrants and refugees persisted to reason main fear as smartly. States will have to now not let determined human beings die neither in Mediterranean nor at their borders. In Syria, Türkiye used to be seeking to revitalise the political procedure, permit protected returns, and get rid of terrorist threats. The world group will have to now not permit the location in Afghanistan to become worse additional. The status quo of a sovereign Palestinian State in keeping with the 1967 borders, with East Jerusalem because the capital, used to be the one method for a simply peace. In Libya, unfastened elections beneath United International locations’ steering had been key to balance and peace. The placement of the Turkish Cypriot other folks will have to be addressed by means of the Council.
The Bone of Competition and India’s Proper of Answer
On Thursday (March 2), the Group of Islamic Cooperation (OIC) raked up the Kashmir factor on the United International locations Human Rights Council (UNHRC).
Its Secretary Common Hissein Brahim Taha reportedly referred to “traits in Afghanistan, the problem of Jammu and Kashmir, the location of the Rohingya Muslim group and the wear and tear to the cultural and spiritual heritage within the liberated territories of Azerbaijan.”
India used to be miffed with the vicious try of OIC, which were prodded to make remarks on Kashmir by means of Turkey and Pakistan up to now. It should be discussed that each Turkey and Pakistan are member States of the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation since 1969.
To make the location worse, Pakistan used the platform of UNHRC to hawk malicious propaganda towards India. As such, on Saturday (March 4), India used its ‘Proper of Answer’ and slammed the neighbouring nation for its sinister time table.
India additionally made references to Turkey within the context of the OIC’s observation and requested the transcontinental nation to chorus from interfering in India’s interior affairs. India used to be at the vanguard of the evacuation project beneath ‘Operation Dost’ after a devastating earthquake hit Turkey and claimed over 40,000 lives.
Whilst faux information peddlers on Whatsapp are suggesting that Turkey backstabbed India in spite of his lend a hand, the observation of Turkey’s Deputy Overseas Minister at UNHRC says another way. He simplest discussed Jammu and Kashmir in his speech, pronouncing that the subject will have to be resolved as according to the UNSC answer on it.
In spite of variations on a couple of problems with Turkey, India performed its humanitarian legal responsibility as a real chief. OIC’s unsolicited remarks and India’s stern reaction can’t be observed as a failure of PM Modi for extending the olive department.
Turkey stood by means of Pakistan over Kashmir factor up to now
Having stated that, Turkey has certainly attempted to meddle in India’s interior affairs up to now. In February 2020, whilst addressing a joint consultation of Pakistan’s Parliament, Erdogan voiced his make stronger to Pakistan on its stand on Kashmir, claiming that the problem of Kashmir can’t be solved via oppression or war however via justice and equity. The Turkish President’s remarks had come 7 months after the revocation of Article 370 and Article 35A that had given a separate standing to Jammu and Kashmir.
Previous to that, in UN Common Meeting in October 2019, Recep Tayyip Erdogan had made a strident speech, supporting Pakistan’s stance on Kashmir whilst exhorting the arena to concentrate on a subject that has now not won ok consideration from the world group.
India had sharply reacted to Erdogan’s observation within the UN meeting, and expressed “deep feel sorry about” over Turkish president’s remarks and categorically requested it to chorus from making statements on India’s “interior issues”. Turkey is likely one of the only a few international locations which have been supporting Pakistan at the Kashmir factor, whilst maximum different international locations believe India’s stand within the subject.
To conclude, India referred to as out Turkey’s interference and increasing make stronger to Pakistan in Kashmir subject. Turkey had raked up Kashmir factor up to now, now not at UNHRC just lately after the earthquake after India prolonged humanitarian aide to Turkey. The 2 are separate incidents and blended as much as additional a deceptive narrative. Whilst the minister did point out Jammu and Kashmir in his speech, he didn’t accuse India of human rights violations within the area, because the viral messages are claiming.
